Live Play Data

Mystical Tutor

· Instant · Dominaria Remastered (DMR)

Live Inclusion

Buy on TCGplayer

Times Brought

1423

Decks Running

683

Median Cast Turn

5.0

Drawn → Played

71%

Format

Multiplayer 1v1

Mystical Tutor is in 9% of tracked Commander decks on Playgroup Live, and when drawn it reaches the stack 71% of the time, with a median first-cast turn of 5.0.

Mystical Tutor sits in 9% of the 7993 Commander decks that have played a tracked game on Playgroup Live. That is a selective inclusion number, one consistent with a card that demands blue in the color identity and rewards spell-heavy strategies rather than generic good-stuff builds.

The core data point is the win-rate lift. Decks that cast Mystical Tutor win at 34%, compared to 24% for decks where the card never left the library. That is a +9.5 percentage-point gap across well-sampled buckets, and the lower bound of the confidence interval stays positive, making this one of the cleaner directional signals in the dataset. Tutoring for the right spell at the right moment appears to matter.

The card is legal in Commander and restricted in Vintage, but banned in Legacy, Duel Commander, Premodern, and Historic. Its restriction in those formats reflects a long-standing consensus about the power of cheap, unconditional library access. In multiplayer Commander, that power shows up in the data: a 1-mana instant that sets up your next draw is almost always the correct play when you have the mana open.

At a glance

9% of tracked Commander decks include Mystical Tutor
71% of drawn copies reach the stack before the game ends
T5.0 median first-cast turn across tracked games
34% win rate in games where Mystical Tutor was cast
+9.5pp win-rate lift over games where it stayed in the library
501 distinct players have brought Mystical Tutor to a tracked game

First-cast turn

n=262

10%

11%

10%

17%

35%

T6-9

10%

T10+

Median 5.0 P25 3 · P75 7 · max 17

On curve 8% (21 / 262 cast on T1) Cast same turn as drawn 43%

The "good card" funnel

1423 brought · 501 players

Brought to game

1423

Ever drawn

370

Reached battlefield

262

Still on board at game end

71%

Of 1423 copies brought to games, 370 were drawn and 262 of those were cast, a funnel that reflects both the inherent variance of a 100-card singleton and how readily players fire this spell when they do find it.

≥ +3.5pp

Players who cast this card win 34% of the time (n=228) , vs 24% when it never left the library (n=846).

When players drew this card but left it in hand, they won 29% (n=98) — about the same as leaving it in the library. Those players survived long enough to draw it, so the gap above is about the card resolving, not just about surviving.

Observed gap +9.5pp; 95% confidence interval +3.5pp to +15.5pp. Correlational, not causal: powerful payoffs also get cast more often in games you are already winning.

Final zone distribution

421 instances

4.3%

Library

2.4%

Battlefield

59.4%

Graveyard

15.9%

Exile

The graveyard is the dominant final zone for Mystical Tutor, exactly as expected for an instant that resolves and goes to the bin. The small library count represents copies that were never interacted with across their game.

Commanders that played this card

in tracked games

The top ten commanders spread inclusion across mono-blue control, Dimir, Izzet, and five-color strategies, a sign that Mystical Tutor is valued wherever blue has access to a rich instant and sorcery suite rather than belonging to one archetype.

Card text

Mystical Tutor

Instant

Search your library for an instant or sorcery card, reveal it, then shuffle and put that card on top.

Dominaria Remastered (DMR) · Rare · Illustrated by Lindsey Look

Frequently Asked

How often is Mystical Tutor drawn in a Commander game?

Across 1217 tracked games where Mystical Tutor was in a deck, it was drawn 26% of the time. That is broadly normal for a singleton in a 100-card deck. Of 370 drawn instances, 71% were cast before the game ended. The remainder largely reflects copies drawn late when mana was committed elsewhere or the game ended before another opportunity arose.

What turn does Mystical Tutor usually get cast?

Median first cast lands on turn 5.0 in multiplayer Commander. The distribution is spread: a cluster of early casts in turns 1-3, likely off an opening hand, and a long tail running into the double digits. The interquartile range runs from turn 4 to turn 7, which means most copies are cast in the mid-game when players know exactly what spell they need to fetch.

Does casting Mystical Tutor actually improve your odds of winning?

The data is directional and well-sampled. Decks that cast Mystical Tutor win at 34% (228 observations). Decks where it never left the library win at 24% (846 observations). That is a +9.5 percentage-point gap, and unlike many cards in the dataset, the lower bound of the confidence interval is positive. Treat it as a strong directional signal rather than a proven causal claim.

Is Mystical Tutor banned anywhere?

Yes, in several formats. It is banned in Legacy, Duel Commander, Historic, and Premodern. It is restricted to one copy in Vintage. It is legal and unrestricted in Commander, Brawl, Timeless, Oathbreaker, and Gladiator. The bans reflect how powerful unconditional instant-speed library access is in formats with strong spell packages.

How concentrated is the data across players?

501 distinct players have brought Mystical Tutor to a tracked game, and the single heaviest contributor accounts for just 3% of all instances. That spread is a genuine strength of this dataset. The pattern is not driven by one or two prolific players, which makes the win-rate signal more credible.

What commanders most often run Mystical Tutor?

Urza, Lord High Artificer and Yuriko, the Tiger's Shadow each lead with 11 decks in the tracked dataset, followed by Fire Lord Azula at 10. The list spans mono-blue artifact strategies, Dimir ninjutsu builds, and multicolor spell-slinger decks. The common thread is a dense instant and sorcery suite where fetching the right answer or combo piece at the right moment is decisive.