Commander Precon Tier List
Playgroup.gg ranks 82 preconstructed Commander decks by win rate across 18,832 tracked games played with the stock decklist, straight out of the box with no upgrades. Real gameplay data, not deck registrations or opinion.
As of September 2026, the strongest out-of-the-box Commander precons by win rate are Planeswalker Party (37.41%), Blame Game (31.05%), and Tricky Terrain (30.02%), from 18,832 tracked stock games.
New to the format? Start with how to play Commander , then pick a deck below.
Precons are ranked by win rate across games played with the stock, unmodified decklist. A deck counts as stock when its non-basic card list exactly matches the precon, so basic-land swaps and printing differences are ignored. Win rates are normalized to a 4-player baseline (25% expected) so games with different pod sizes are weighted fairly. A precon needs at least 20 tracked stock games from at least 10 distinct registered pilots to qualify, so a single playgroup cannot dominate the ranking. Most precons land at or below the 25% line, exactly what you would expect from an out-of-the-box deck, so the higher tiers mark the precons that overperform before any upgrades. Data comes from games tracked through the Playgroup.gg app and online games played with Playgroup Live.
The 18,832 stock-decklist games behind this ranking are a filtered slice of Playgroup's 700,000+ recorded Commander games overall.
S-Tier: Dominant Precons (35%+ Win Rate)
Winning 40% more often than expected in 4-player pods.
A-Tier: Strong Precons (30-35% Win Rate)
Consistently above the 25% expected baseline.
B-Tier: Average Precons (23-30% Win Rate)
Near the expected win rate for 4-player Commander.
Faded win rates indicate low sample size (fewer than 40 stock games). Tier placement may shift as more data is collected.
C-Tier: Below Average Precons (18-23% Win Rate)
Underperforming the statistical baseline.
Faded win rates indicate low sample size (fewer than 40 stock games). Tier placement may shift as more data is collected.
D-Tier: Weak Precons (Below 18% Win Rate)
Winning significantly less than expected.
Faded win rates indicate low sample size (fewer than 40 stock games). Tier placement may shift as more data is collected.
All Commander Precons by Set
Every preconstructed Commander deck we track: 92 decks across 26 sets (2022-2026), including upcoming decks and precons still gathering game data. Each links to its full decklist; rows with enough stock games show their measured win rate from the tier list above.
The best Commander precons for beginners
A high win rate is not the same thing as a good first deck, so the top of this ranking is not automatically where a new player should start. Wizards builds two lines specifically for beginners, and both are cheaper and simpler than the Commander precons that ship alongside a modern set.
The five Starter Commander Decks from 2022 are two colors each with one clear plan, and every card in them is a reprint. The five single-color Foundations Commander Decks released on October 2, 2026 are the current version of the same idea. Both sets are listed in the directory above, and any deck of theirs with enough tracked stock games is ranked in the tiers.
If you have not played the format yet, read how to play Commander first, then playtest any precon on this page in your browser before buying the box.
Frequently Asked
What is the best Commander precon?
What is the most powerful Commander precon ever?
How many Commander precons are there?
Which Commander precon is best for beginners?
How is the Commander precon tier list calculated?
Are Commander precons worth buying?
Do upgrades make a precon better?
Why isn't a precon on this list?
How is this different from EDHREC?
More Commander Data
Explore the rest of Playgroup.gg's data-backed Commander rankings, all from real games players track at the table or log after playing.