Most Fun Commanders
Which Commanders are the most fun to actually pilot? Ranked from 1,497,169 real post-game fun ratings players gave their own games, standardized to a neutral win rate so a deck cannot climb just by winning.
Post-game self-ratings behind the rankings below.
With at least 300 ratings from 10+ pilots across the fun-rated subset of Playgroup's 690,000+ recorded Commander games.
Average stars pilots give games they win versus games they lose.
What are the most fun commanders in MTG?
The most fun Commanders to pilot right now are The Celestial Toymaker (4.09), Yusri, Fortune's Flame (4.06), and The Second Doctor (4.01), across all tracked games. Every Commander game is rated 1 to 5 by the player who piloted the deck, right after they finish playing. Because winners always rate their games higher, the score standardizes to a neutral win rate: it averages the fun on won and lost games separately, then weights the losing side more heavily, so winning does not buy fun points.
The top 100 most fun commanders to pilot
Most fun even when you lose
Anyone can enjoy a win. These commanders keep the game fun in defeat, rated by pilots who lost the game they were rating, among decks with enough losing games to measure.
Looking for fun Commander decks?
Ready-to-play precons are the fastest way to a fun table, and you can try any of them free in your browser.
The method, in plain language
- Pilots rate their own game 1 to 5 right after playing, so this measures fun to PILOT a commander, not to play against one.
- Winners rate games higher: across tracked games the average is 4.33 out of 5 when a pilot wins versus 3.44 when they lose, a gap of 0.89 stars. A raw fun average would just re-rank commanders by win rate.
- To strip out that bonus we average the winning-game and losing-game ratings separately, then combine them as 0.25 times the winning average plus 0.75 times the losing average. Weighting the losing side more heavily standardizes every commander to a neutral outcome.
- A commander needs at least 300 fun ratings across all tracked games from at least 10 distinct pilots to be ranked. If either side has fewer than 10 ratings we substitute the site-wide average for that side.
- Honest caveat: this is self-reported, and players who skip rating can bias the sample. It reflects how the people who did rate felt about piloting the deck.
- Card names and artwork come from Scryfall. The ratings themselves are not sourced from anywhere: every game result and fun rating on this page is Playgroup.gg's own first-party data, recorded by players in our game tracker.
- Computed 14 Sep 2026 and refreshed every 6 hours.