Data-Backed · Win Rates

Commander Tier List

Playgroup.gg ranks 1188 commanders into five tiers by win rate across 558,894 tracked casual Commander games from the all time. The first Commander tier list based on real gameplay data, not opinions or deck registrations.

1,188
Ranked
558,894
Games
Methodology
Last Updated

Tiers are assigned by win rate across all tracked Commander games. Win rates are normalized to a 4-player baseline (25% expected) so games with different pod sizes are weighted fairly. A commander needs at least 250 tracked games to qualify, and those games must come from at least 10 distinct registered pilots so a single playgroup cannot dominate the ranking. Data comes from games recorded playing paper magic through the Playgroup.gg app and online games played with Playgroup Live. Win rates are calculated from both registered-deck and guest-commander participations.

S 35%+ Win Rate
A 30-35% Win Rate
B 23-30% Win Rate
C 18-23% Win Rate
D Below 18% Win Rate
S
35%+ Win Rate

S-Tier: Dominant Commanders (35%+ Win Rate)

31
Entries

Winning 40% more often than expected in 4-player pods.

1 S
47.34% · 432 games
2 S
40.5% · 363 games
3 S
40.48% · 365 games
4 S
40.47% · 1438 games
5 S
39.27% · 254 games
6 S
39.18% · 714 games
8 S
38.85% · 778 games
9 S
38.69% · 495 games
10 S
38.3% · 624 games
11 S
38.24% · 931 games
12 S
37.82% · 312 games
13 S
37.82% · 1229 games
14 S
37.54% · 2832 games
15 S
16 S
36.64% · 608 games
17 S
36.63% · 746 games
18 S
36.6% · 291 games
20 S
36.27% · 457 games
21 S
36.12% · 744 games
22 S
36.1% · 428 games
24 S
35.71% · 280 games
25 S
35.63% · 1421 games
26 S
35.5% · 631 games
27 S
35.41% · 2063 games
29 S
30 S
35.21% · 316 games
31 S
35.06% · 4231 games
A
30-35% Win Rate

A-Tier: Strong Commanders (30-35% Win Rate)

157
Entries

Consistently above the 25% expected baseline.

1 A
34.95% · 3345 games
2 A
34.82% · 2230 games
3 A
34.58% · 313 games
4 A
34.55% · 280 games
5 A
34.48% · 828 games
6 A
34.44% · 376 games
7 A
34.41% · 728 games
8 A
34.39% · 1602 games
9 A
34.32% · 598 games
10 A
34.28% · 1538 games
11 A
34.03% · 963 games
13 A
33.84% · 1442 games
14 A
33.77% · 7949 games
15 A
33.59% · 320 games
16 A
33.58% · 501 games
17 A
33.56% · 698 games
18 A
33.51% · 1809 games
19 A
33.48% · 1017 games
20 A
33.42% · 5096 games
21 A
33.35% · 3201 games
22 A
33.31% · 2700 games
23 A
33.23% · 313 games
24 A
33.21% · 652 games
25 A
33.19% · 745 games
26 A
33.15% · 709 games
27 A
33.1% · 954 games
28 A
33.08% · 2117 games
29 A
33.06% · 310 games
30 A
33.06% · 921 games
31 A
33.03% · 333 games
32 A
32.95% · 3454 games
33 A
32.91% · 496 games
34 A
32.85% · 748 games
35 A
32.79% · 475 games
36 A
32.73% · 1459 games
38 A
32.71% · 1806 games
39 A
32.71% · 4229 games
41 A
32.63% · 1629 games
42 A
32.56% · 377 games
43 A
32.53% · 269 games
44 A
32.48% · 324 games
45 A
32.47% · 378 games
46 A
32.35% · 476 games
47 A
32.32% · 471 games
48 A
32.29% · 648 games
49 A
32.24% · 3559 games
50 A
32.17% · 1307 games
51 A
32.16% · 1247 games
52 A
32.14% · 343 games
53 A
32.13% · 414 games
54 A
32.11% · 6254 games
55 A
32.11% · 693 games
56 A
32.1% · 3369 games
57 A
32.06% · 1466 games
58 A
32.05% · 532 games
59 A
31.99% · 390 games
60 A
31.97% · 276 games
61 A
31.97% · 1054 games
62 A
31.94% · 1073 games
63 A
31.93% · 574 games
64 A
31.9% · 1720 games
65 A
31.89% · 370 games
66 A
31.86% · 612 games
67 A
31.82% · 1430 games
68 A
31.8% · 1033 games
69 A
31.76% · 710 games
70 A
31.73% · 1653 games
71 A
31.7% · 1276 games
72 A
31.61% · 2144 games
73 A
31.52% · 4323 games
74 A
31.52% · 322 games
75 A
31.52% · 5906 games
76 A
31.5% · 650 games
77 A
31.48% · 1567 games
78 A
31.47% · 5197 games
79 A
31.47% · 927 games
80 A
31.45% · 372 games
81 A
31.45% · 376 games
82 A
31.43% · 626 games
83 A
31.43% · 319 games
84 A
31.42% · 576 games
85 A
31.4% · 723 games
86 A
31.38% · 290 games
87 A
31.38% · 4696 games
88 A
31.33% · 652 games
89 A
31.31% · 2768 games
90 A
31.31% · 2232 games
91 A
31.3% · 2322 games
92 A
31.21% · 878 games
93 A
31.2% · 500 games
94 A
31.16% · 1692 games
95 A
31.1% · 258 games
96 A
31.1% · 549 games
97 A
31.1% · 8006 games
98 A
31.09% · 2922 games
99 A
31.03% · 1751 games
100 A
31.02% · 3455 games
101 A
31.01% · 258 games
102 A
31.01% · 691 games
103 A
31.0% · 1188 games
104 A
30.99% · 2642 games
105 A
30.97% · 1663 games
106 A
30.95% · 1475 games
107 A
30.9% · 1424 games
108 A
30.89% · 760 games
109 A
30.82% · 1367 games
111 A
30.78% · 515 games
112 A
30.76% · 2628 games
113 A
30.75% · 2940 games
115 A
30.71% · 372 games
117 A
30.68% · 894 games
118 A
30.65% · 376 games
119 A
30.65% · 323 games
120 A
30.64% · 2120 games
121 A
30.63% · 1309 games
122 A
30.63% · 1795 games
123 A
30.54% · 1015 games
125 A
30.49% · 2013 games
126 A
30.46% · 1691 games
127 A
30.43% · 1538 games
128 A
30.41% · 10374 games
129 A
30.37% · 1782 games
130 A
30.37% · 2995 games
132 A
30.34% · 2078 games
133 A
30.32% · 2174 games
134 A
30.29% · 6363 games
135 A
30.28% · 13696 games
136 A
30.28% · 407 games
137 A
30.28% · 1207 games
138 A
30.27% · 982 games
139 A
30.27% · 1785 games
140 A
30.26% · 3358 games
141 A
30.22% · 1393 games
142 A
30.21% · 384 games
143 A
30.2% · 269 games
144 A
30.17% · 7218 games
145 A
30.16% · 1487 games
146 A
30.16% · 872 games
147 A
30.16% · 1706 games
148 A
30.15% · 743 games
149 A
30.14% · 798 games
150 A
30.11% · 2070 games
151 A
30.09% · 265 games
152 A
30.09% · 565 games
153 A
30.08% · 1123 games
154 A
30.06% · 1444 games
155 A
30.05% · 297 games
156 A
30.0% · 4437 games
157 A
30.0% · 7939 games
B
23-30% Win Rate

B-Tier: Average Commanders (23-30% Win Rate)

632
Entries

Near the expected win rate for 4-player Commander.

1 B
29.97% · 759 games
2 B
29.95% · 935 games
3 B
29.93% · 1090 games
4 B
29.91% · 3710 games
5 B
29.9% · 4178 games
6 B
29.9% · 1261 games
7 B
29.88% · 8546 games
8 B
29.87% · 1284 games
9 B
29.86% · 2611 games
10 B
29.84% · 950 games
11 B
29.83% · 331 games
12 B
29.82% · 799 games
13 B
29.8% · 1822 games
14 B
29.78% · 356 games
15 B
29.76% · 457 games
16 B
29.76% · 289 games
17 B
29.74% · 269 games
18 B
29.73% · 1290 games
19 B
29.73% · 534 games
20 B
29.7% · 1591 games
21 B
29.68% · 326 games
22 B
29.67% · 3055 games
23 B
29.66% · 2424 games
24 B
29.66% · 1282 games
25 B
29.64% · 760 games
26 B
29.63% · 3896 games
27 B
29.62% · 433 games
28 B
29.61% · 11487 games
29 B
29.61% · 580 games
30 B
29.56% · 592 games
31 B
29.55% · 1671 games
32 B
29.55% · 462 games
34 B
29.5% · 705 games
35 B
29.49% · 3240 games
37 B
29.47% · 1085 games
38 B
29.45% · 3858 games
39 B
29.44% · 715 games
40 B
29.42% · 7407 games
41 B
29.42% · 1148 games
42 B
29.42% · 928 games
43 B
29.39% · 2379 games
44 B
29.38% · 360 games
45 B
29.37% · 303 games
46 B
29.37% · 733 games
47 B
29.34% · 1032 games
48 B
29.33% · 254 games
49 B
29.33% · 537 games
50 B
29.29% · 425 games
51 B
29.29% · 752 games
52 B
29.28% · 1022 games
53 B
29.26% · 323 games
54 B
29.25% · 842 games
55 B
29.24% · 1337 games
56 B
29.23% · 1087 games
57 B
29.21% · 1373 games
58 B
29.2% · 5681 games
59 B
29.19% · 1354 games
60 B
29.19% · 3016 games
61 B
29.15% · 5381 games
62 B
29.13% · 1957 games
63 B
29.12% · 346 games
64 B
29.08% · 2725 games
65 B
29.05% · 1400 games
66 B
29.04% · 2896 games
67 B
29.01% · 1198 games
68 B
28.99% · 2356 games
69 B
28.98% · 2109 games
70 B
28.97% · 510 games
71 B
28.89% · 893 games
72 B
28.85% · 409 games
74 B
28.82% · 2292 games
75 B
28.8% · 16835 games
76 B
28.79% · 277 games
77 B
28.78% · 2110 games
78 B
28.75% · 860 games
79 B
28.71% · 357 games
80 B
28.7% · 2148 games
81 B
28.68% · 441 games
82 B
28.68% · 564 games
83 B
28.67% · 484 games
84 B
28.66% · 314 games
85 B
28.65% · 1225 games
86 B
28.65% · 1363 games
87 B
28.64% · 295 games
88 B
28.63% · 516 games
89 B
28.62% · 469 games
90 B
28.62% · 269 games
91 B
28.61% · 353 games
92 B
28.61% · 5487 games
93 B
28.59% · 550 games
94 B
28.56% · 933 games
95 B
28.55% · 3532 games
96 B
28.53% · 1564 games
97 B
28.52% · 476 games
98 B
28.5% · 664 games
99 B
28.49% · 538 games
100 B
28.45% · 2641 games
101 B
28.44% · 1939 games
102 B
28.43% · 466 games
103 B
28.43% · 466 games
104 B
28.42% · 834 games
105 B
28.4% · 309 games
106 B
28.38% · 400 games
107 B
28.37% · 3974 games
108 B
28.35% · 418 games
109 B
28.34% · 1363 games
110 B
28.33% · 510 games
111 B
112 B
28.31% · 4167 games
113 B
28.31% · 7714 games
114 B
28.25% · 1015 games
115 B
28.25% · 10154 games
116 B
28.25% · 616 games
117 B
28.23% · 541 games
118 B
28.22% · 2630 games
119 B
28.2% · 2177 games
120 B
28.17% · 5837 games
122 B
28.17% · 679 games
123 B
28.16% · 1154 games
124 B
28.15% · 2125 games
125 B
28.15% · 1214 games
126 B
28.14% · 510 games
127 B
28.1% · 709 games
128 B
28.1% · 814 games
129 B
28.09% · 559 games
130 B
28.08% · 1014 games
131 B
28.08% · 5420 games
132 B
28.07% · 2764 games
133 B
28.06% · 335 games
134 B
28.05% · 606 games
135 B
28.05% · 6289 games
136 B
28.04% · 3209 games
137 B
28.01% · 340 games
138 B
28.01% · 823 games
139 B
27.99% · 2040 games
140 B
141 B
27.98% · 578 games
142 B
27.96% · 1443 games
143 B
27.95% · 7797 games
144 B
27.93% · 350 games
145 B
27.92% · 659 games
146 B
27.92% · 2006 games
147 B
27.91% · 1519 games
148 B
27.9% · 1173 games
149 B
27.9% · 621 games
150 B
27.9% · 682 games
151 B
27.88% · 2673 games
152 B
27.85% · 5225 games
153 B
27.84% · 4440 games
154 B
27.84% · 695 games
155 B
27.82% · 7695 games
156 B
27.81% · 1910 games
157 B
27.79% · 3222 games
158 B
27.79% · 2625 games
159 B
27.78% · 1133 games
160 B
27.77% · 2381 games
161 B
27.76% · 544 games
162 B
27.75% · 710 games
163 B
27.73% · 384 games
164 B
27.73% · 558 games
165 B
27.73% · 1979 games
166 B
27.72% · 2356 games
167 B
27.72% · 709 games
168 B
27.71% · 1575 games
169 B
27.67% · 609 games
170 B
27.63% · 1186 games
171 B
27.62% · 2211 games
172 B
27.61% · 479 games
173 B
27.58% · 776 games
174 B
27.58% · 912 games
175 B
27.57% · 5131 games
176 B
27.57% · 409 games
177 B
27.56% · 499 games
178 B
27.55% · 2128 games
179 B
27.55% · 4898 games
180 B
27.53% · 1097 games
181 B
27.52% · 873 games
182 B
27.49% · 513 games
183 B
27.45% · 866 games
184 B
27.44% · 481 games
185 B
27.43% · 607 games
186 B
27.4% · 895 games
187 B
27.39% · 900 games
188 B
27.37% · 4884 games
189 B
27.36% · 360 games
191 B
27.35% · 2232 games
192 B
27.33% · 268 games
193 B
27.33% · 1695 games
194 B
27.31% · 1005 games
195 B
27.31% · 5698 games
196 B
27.3% · 499 games
197 B
27.3% · 499 games
198 B
27.28% · 560 games
200 B
27.25% · 523 games
201 B
27.24% · 368 games
202 B
27.24% · 302 games
203 B
27.23% · 1568 games
204 B
27.23% · 561 games
205 B
27.23% · 3571 games
206 B
27.22% · 7831 games
207 B
27.22% · 677 games
208 B
27.21% · 418 games
209 B
27.2% · 352 games
210 B
27.19% · 467 games
211 B
27.19% · 263 games
212 B
27.16% · 1972 games
213 B
27.15% · 1247 games
214 B
27.14% · 968 games
215 B
27.14% · 642 games
216 B
27.13% · 786 games
217 B
27.13% · 833 games
218 B
27.1% · 2705 games
219 B
27.09% · 1803 games
220 B
27.08% · 1512 games
222 B
27.02% · 903 games
223 B
27.02% · 1461 games
224 B
27.01% · 684 games
225 B
27.01% · 573 games
226 B
26.99% · 251 games
227 B
26.98% · 567 games
228 B
229 B
26.96% · 8211 games
230 B
26.95% · 743 games
231 B
26.95% · 359 games
232 B
26.94% · 1157 games
233 B
26.92% · 3782 games
234 B
26.92% · 809 games
235 B
26.91% · 1242 games
236 B
26.91% · 8033 games
237 B
26.9% · 3949 games
238 B
26.89% · 2023 games
239 B
26.89% · 807 games
240 B
26.85% · 972 games
241 B
26.83% · 452 games
242 B
26.82% · 4724 games
243 B
26.81% · 718 games
244 B
26.81% · 498 games
245 B
26.81% · 761 games
246 B
26.81% · 9343 games
247 B
249 B
26.8% · 640 games
250 B
26.79% · 742 games
251 B
26.78% · 1392 games
252 B
26.77% · 310 games
253 B
26.77% · 381 games
254 B
26.75% · 1117 games
255 B
26.74% · 689 games
256 B
257 B
26.73% · 9104 games
258 B
26.72% · 2175 games
259 B
26.72% · 1499 games
260 B
26.69% · 14130 games
261 B
26.67% · 1152 games
262 B
26.67% · 1411 games
263 B
26.67% · 1231 games
264 B
26.66% · 4085 games
265 B
26.66% · 678 games
266 B
26.65% · 771 games
267 B
26.64% · 350 games
268 B
26.64% · 382 games
269 B
26.63% · 597 games
270 B
26.62% · 493 games
271 B
26.61% · 2171 games
272 B
26.6% · 1095 games
273 B
26.59% · 5001 games
274 B
26.57% · 414 games
275 B
26.56% · 2297 games
276 B
26.54% · 617 games
277 B
26.53% · 277 games
278 B
26.53% · 10206 games
279 B
26.53% · 836 games
280 B
26.52% · 395 games
281 B
26.5% · 366 games
282 B
26.5% · 802 games
283 B
26.49% · 771 games
284 B
26.49% · 606 games
285 B
26.47% · 8463 games
286 B
26.43% · 472 games
287 B
26.36% · 478 games
288 B
26.35% · 591 games
289 B
26.35% · 2921 games
290 B
26.35% · 629 games
291 B
26.32% · 453 games
292 B
26.32% · 2070 games
293 B
26.3% · 366 games
294 B
26.29% · 271 games
295 B
26.28% · 3176 games
296 B
26.27% · 1578 games
297 B
26.26% · 11759 games
298 B
26.25% · 260 games
299 B
300 B
26.23% · 2032 games
301 B
26.22% · 411 games
303 B
26.2% · 417 games
304 B
26.19% · 1988 games
305 B
26.19% · 3986 games
306 B
26.13% · 3361 games
307 B
26.11% · 1480 games
308 B
26.1% · 385 games
309 B
26.1% · 4072 games
310 B
26.1% · 296 games
311 B
26.09% · 984 games
312 B
26.08% · 3071 games
313 B
26.06% · 377 games
314 B
26.05% · 4424 games
316 B
26.05% · 12851 games
317 B
26.05% · 287 games
318 B
26.04% · 2022 games
319 B
26.04% · 723 games
320 B
26.04% · 338 games
321 B
26.03% · 5691 games
322 B
26.02% · 9414 games
324 B
26.0% · 3421 games
325 B
26.0% · 751 games
326 B
25.98% · 613 games
327 B
25.98% · 2538 games
328 B
25.97% · 7364 games
329 B
25.96% · 314 games
330 B
25.95% · 2069 games
332 B
25.93% · 323 games
333 B
25.91% · 274 games
334 B
25.9% · 1109 games
335 B
25.9% · 1141 games
336 B
25.9% · 1563 games
337 B
25.87% · 548 games
338 B
25.86% · 4179 games
339 B
25.85% · 2009 games
340 B
25.84% · 1602 games
341 B
25.83% · 723 games
342 B
25.83% · 303 games
343 B
25.82% · 2871 games
344 B
25.81% · 1458 games
345 B
25.8% · 5122 games
346 B
25.8% · 376 games
347 B
25.79% · 9071 games
348 B
25.77% · 323 games
349 B
25.77% · 518 games
350 B
25.74% · 4399 games
351 B
25.72% · 2286 games
352 B
25.71% · 670 games
353 B
25.69% · 1094 games
354 B
25.67% · 929 games
355 B
25.65% · 386 games
356 B
25.64% · 1013 games
357 B
25.64% · 1055 games
358 B
25.64% · 861 games
359 B
25.63% · 955 games
360 B
25.61% · 1060 games
361 B
25.6% · 374 games
362 B
25.6% · 250 games
364 B
25.58% · 772 games
365 B
25.58% · 1515 games
366 B
25.56% · 2361 games
367 B
25.56% · 448 games
368 B
25.55% · 632 games
369 B
25.55% · 1230 games
370 B
25.53% · 518 games
371 B
25.52% · 11355 games
372 B
25.5% · 849 games
373 B
25.49% · 456 games
374 B
25.48% · 1303 games
375 B
25.47% · 580 games
376 B
25.47% · 851 games
377 B
25.47% · 1125 games
379 B
25.44% · 563 games
380 B
25.43% · 467 games
381 B
25.42% · 1834 games
382 B
25.42% · 8246 games
383 B
25.41% · 1585 games
384 B
25.41% · 734 games
385 B
25.39% · 772 games
386 B
25.36% · 413 games
387 B
25.33% · 1692 games
388 B
25.32% · 1182 games
389 B
25.32% · 1111 games
390 B
25.31% · 397 games
391 B
25.29% · 867 games
392 B
25.28% · 453 games
393 B
25.27% · 13231 games
394 B
25.25% · 297 games
395 B
25.25% · 1289 games
396 B
25.25% · 2105 games
398 B
25.2% · 255 games
399 B
25.18% · 552 games
400 B
25.18% · 1120 games
401 B
25.17% · 289 games
402 B
25.17% · 2346 games
403 B
25.17% · 1646 games
404 B
25.12% · 811 games
405 B
25.12% · 4175 games
406 B
25.1% · 263 games
407 B
25.07% · 4565 games
408 B
25.07% · 381 games
409 B
25.05% · 1627 games
410 B
25.04% · 584 games
411 B
25.04% · 1339 games
412 B
25.03% · 792 games
413 B
25.03% · 5775 games
414 B
25.02% · 2165 games
415 B
25.01% · 1772 games
416 B
25.0% · 321 games
417 B
25.0% · 967 games
418 B
25.0% · 366 games
419 B
24.97% · 882 games
420 B
24.96% · 630 games
421 B
24.95% · 481 games
422 B
423 B
24.94% · 1206 games
424 B
24.93% · 347 games
425 B
24.92% · 6759 games
428 B
24.9% · 1463 games
429 B
24.9% · 2429 games
430 B
24.89% · 690 games
431 B
24.89% · 455 games
432 B
24.87% · 3465 games
433 B
24.86% · 730 games
434 B
24.85% · 334 games
435 B
24.85% · 5152 games
436 B
24.84% · 1690 games
437 B
24.84% · 4129 games
438 B
24.82% · 697 games
439 B
24.81% · 4676 games
440 B
24.81% · 789 games
441 B
24.8% · 1877 games
442 B
24.79% · 1204 games
443 B
24.79% · 480 games
444 B
24.79% · 479 games
445 B
24.78% · 5799 games
446 B
24.77% · 11752 games
447 B
24.76% · 1471 games
448 B
24.76% · 1046 games
449 B
24.74% · 387 games
450 B
24.73% · 283 games
451 B
24.73% · 7390 games
452 B
24.71% · 3203 games
453 B
24.7% · 337 games
454 B
24.69% · 405 games
455 B
24.68% · 3684 games
456 B
24.67% · 1922 games
457 B
24.67% · 2259 games
458 B
24.66% · 368 games
459 B
24.66% · 1470 games
460 B
24.65% · 360 games
461 B
24.65% · 777 games
462 B
24.63% · 1154 games
463 B
24.63% · 10854 games
464 B
24.62% · 6454 games
465 B
24.61% · 511 games
466 B
24.6% · 8432 games
467 B
24.56% · 2273 games
468 B
24.55% · 447 games
469 B
24.53% · 1692 games
470 B
24.53% · 316 games
471 B
24.48% · 1439 games
472 B
24.46% · 1016 games
473 B
24.45% · 547 games
474 B
24.44% · 1291 games
475 B
24.42% · 7818 games
476 B
24.42% · 302 games
477 B
24.42% · 431 games
478 B
24.42% · 1076 games
479 B
Six
24.42% · 387 games
480 B
24.41% · 464 games
481 B
24.4% · 1134 games
482 B
24.4% · 1537 games
483 B
24.4% · 497 games
485 B
24.36% · 1021 games
486 B
24.35% · 2939 games
487 B
24.33% · 263 games
488 B
24.33% · 483 games
489 B
24.31% · 728 games
490 B
24.31% · 763 games
491 B
24.31% · 1771 games
492 B
24.29% · 991 games
493 B
24.29% · 1303 games
494 B
24.28% · 3916 games
495 B
24.23% · 420 games
496 B
24.21% · 318 games
497 B
24.21% · 413 games
498 B
24.2% · 503 games
499 B
24.18% · 335 games
500 B
24.18% · 487 games
501 B
24.18% · 1213 games
503 B
24.16% · 444 games
504 B
24.14% · 1190 games
505 B
24.12% · 4556 games
506 B
24.12% · 794 games
507 B
24.12% · 1047 games
508 B
24.11% · 1297 games
509 B
24.11% · 1706 games
510 B
24.09% · 1567 games
511 B
24.09% · 494 games
512 B
24.09% · 1180 games
513 B
24.07% · 1051 games
514 B
24.07% · 1616 games
515 B
24.07% · 699 games
516 B
24.07% · 3544 games
517 B
24.05% · 3090 games
518 B
24.05% · 2475 games
519 B
24.04% · 1439 games
520 B
24.04% · 338 games
521 B
24.02% · 6295 games
522 B
24.02% · 1375 games
523 B
24.01% · 8266 games
524 B
24.01% · 4155 games
525 B
24.01% · 378 games
526 B
24.01% · 955 games
527 B
24.0% · 552 games
528 B
24.0% · 902 games
529 B
23.99% · 668 games
530 B
23.99% · 741 games
531 B
23.99% · 764 games
532 B
23.98% · 342 games
534 B
23.95% · 2615 games
535 B
23.94% · 3952 games
536 B
23.92% · 302 games
537 B
23.91% · 529 games
538 B
23.91% · 1143 games
539 B
23.91% · 5095 games
540 B
23.9% · 3865 games
541 B
23.89% · 314 games
542 B
23.88% · 896 games
543 B
23.87% · 1041 games
544 B
23.85% · 502 games
545 B
23.85% · 871 games
546 B
23.85% · 629 games
547 B
23.82% · 1508 games
548 B
23.82% · 361 games
549 B
23.8% · 831 games
550 B
23.8% · 270 games
551 B
23.79% · 1321 games
552 B
23.79% · 1030 games
553 B
23.78% · 267 games
554 B
23.77% · 917 games
555 B
23.77% · 2095 games
556 B
23.77% · 813 games
557 B
23.76% · 726 games
558 B
23.76% · 463 games
559 B
23.75% · 7302 games
560 B
23.75% · 1098 games
561 B
23.73% · 805 games
562 B
23.73% · 706 games
563 B
23.72% · 1411 games
564 B
23.72% · 821 games
565 B
23.7% · 347 games
566 B
23.7% · 289 games
567 B
23.69% · 705 games
568 B
23.69% · 818 games
569 B
23.66% · 897 games
570 B
23.65% · 500 games
571 B
23.64% · 1231 games
572 B
23.63% · 419 games
573 B
23.62% · 345 games
574 B
23.62% · 471 games
575 B
23.62% · 398 games
576 B
23.6% · 1714 games
577 B
23.58% · 1482 games
578 B
23.57% · 1313 games
579 B
23.57% · 402 games
580 B
23.57% · 401 games
581 B
23.54% · 582 games
582 B
23.53% · 290 games
583 B
23.52% · 626 games
584 B
23.52% · 422 games
585 B
23.52% · 354 games
586 B
23.51% · 791 games
587 B
23.51% · 353 games
588 B
23.51% · 419 games
589 B
23.51% · 2694 games
590 B
23.5% · 351 games
591 B
23.48% · 2946 games
592 B
23.48% · 394 games
593 B
23.47% · 702 games
594 B
23.46% · 1591 games
595 B
23.45% · 760 games
596 B
23.45% · 808 games
597 B
598 B
23.45% · 549 games
599 B
23.45% · 821 games
600 B
23.45% · 5633 games
601 B
23.45% · 531 games
602 B
23.44% · 1863 games
603 B
23.44% · 529 games
604 B
23.43% · 255 games
605 B
23.41% · 1336 games
606 B
23.4% · 562 games
607 B
23.38% · 1701 games
608 B
23.37% · 950 games
609 B
23.35% · 1256 games
610 B
23.35% · 1512 games
611 B
23.32% · 804 games
612 B
23.31% · 356 games
613 B
23.31% · 666 games
614 B
23.28% · 262 games
615 B
23.26% · 1902 games
616 B
23.25% · 2096 games
617 B
23.24% · 866 games
618 B
23.22% · 1137 games
619 B
23.21% · 432 games
620 B
23.17% · 916 games
621 B
23.15% · 473 games
622 B
23.13% · 268 games
623 B
23.13% · 723 games
624 B
23.12% · 412 games
625 B
23.12% · 1023 games
627 B
23.08% · 585 games
628 B
23.06% · 5035 games
629 B
23.05% · 7192 games
630 B
23.04% · 3833 games
631 B
23.01% · 590 games
632 B
23.01% · 3035 games
C
18-23% Win Rate

C-Tier: Below Average Commanders (18-23% Win Rate)

307
Entries

Underperforming the statistical baseline.

1 C
22.99% · 634 games
2 C
22.97% · 1159 games
3 C
22.97% · 345 games
4 C
22.96% · 858 games
5 C
22.95% · 1087 games
6 C
22.95% · 1646 games
7 C
22.94% · 425 games
8 C
22.92% · 864 games
9 C
22.91% · 7311 games
10 C
22.91% · 275 games
11 C
22.89% · 1446 games
12 C
22.89% · 675 games
13 C
22.89% · 1005 games
14 C
22.88% · 943 games
15 C
22.86% · 1836 games
16 C
22.86% · 362 games
17 C
22.85% · 1338 games
18 C
22.85% · 2694 games
19 C
22.84% · 1180 games
20 C
22.84% · 786 games
21 C
22.83% · 438 games
22 C
22.83% · 2138 games
23 C
22.82% · 1673 games
24 C
22.81% · 331 games
25 C
22.76% · 2692 games
26 C
22.74% · 2569 games
27 C
22.74% · 2391 games
28 C
22.72% · 757 games
29 C
22.72% · 1696 games
30 C
22.69% · 607 games
31 C
22.67% · 1311 games
32 C
22.64% · 3344 games
33 C
22.64% · 5529 games
34 C
22.63% · 306 games
35 C
22.62% · 284 games
36 C
22.62% · 1798 games
37 C
22.6% · 511 games
38 C
22.57% · 309 games
39 C
22.57% · 422 games
40 C
22.54% · 285 games
41 C
22.54% · 844 games
42 C
22.54% · 752 games
43 C
22.53% · 2158 games
44 C
22.53% · 1365 games
45 C
22.52% · 878 games
46 C
22.52% · 775 games
47 C
22.51% · 553 games
48 C
22.51% · 301 games
49 C
22.5% · 370 games
50 C
22.5% · 859 games
51 C
22.46% · 473 games
52 C
22.45% · 685 games
53 C
22.44% · 2064 games
54 C
22.39% · 2225 games
55 C
22.37% · 2630 games
56 C
22.36% · 833 games
57 C
22.36% · 700 games
58 C
22.36% · 700 games
60 C
22.35% · 1472 games
61 C
22.32% · 5658 games
62 C
22.32% · 1537 games
63 C
22.32% · 1332 games
64 C
22.32% · 1155 games
65 C
22.28% · 515 games
66 C
22.27% · 1053 games
67 C
22.26% · 301 games
68 C
22.25% · 710 games
69 C
22.24% · 272 games
70 C
22.24% · 1213 games
71 C
22.2% · 3087 games
72 C
22.2% · 1453 games
73 C
22.17% · 697 games
74 C
22.16% · 317 games
75 C
22.15% · 4028 games
76 C
22.15% · 342 games
77 C
22.14% · 499 games
78 C
22.13% · 1348 games
79 C
22.11% · 900 games
80 C
22.1% · 345 games
81 C
22.09% · 507 games
82 C
22.09% · 927 games
83 C
22.08% · 479 games
84 C
22.07% · 1914 games
85 C
22.04% · 304 games
86 C
22.04% · 878 games
87 C
22.01% · 293 games
88 C
22.01% · 4299 games
89 C
21.99% · 1684 games
90 C
21.98% · 1392 games
91 C
21.97% · 322 games
92 C
21.97% · 264 games
93 C
21.96% · 2884 games
94 C
21.95% · 844 games
95 C
21.94% · 1137 games
96 C
21.94% · 5066 games
97 C
21.94% · 768 games
98 C
21.92% · 624 games
99 C
21.9% · 1041 games
100 C
21.9% · 588 games
101 C
21.88% · 272 games
102 C
21.86% · 263 games
103 C
21.86% · 263 games
104 C
21.86% · 3537 games
105 C
21.84% · 388 games
106 C
21.83% · 434 games
107 C
21.8% · 1163 games
108 C
21.8% · 359 games
109 C
21.77% · 2478 games
110 C
21.75% · 385 games
111 C
21.74% · 345 games
112 C
21.73% · 765 games
113 C
21.73% · 474 games
114 C
21.73% · 321 games
115 C
21.71% · 487 games
116 C
21.71% · 631 games
117 C
21.71% · 2391 games
118 C
21.68% · 504 games
119 C
21.66% · 957 games
120 C
21.61% · 302 games
121 C
21.58% · 2950 games
122 C
21.58% · 2561 games
123 C
21.58% · 300 games
124 C
21.58% · 628 games
125 C
21.52% · 316 games
126 C
21.51% · 2654 games
127 C
21.46% · 1892 games
128 C
21.46% · 473 games
129 C
21.42% · 1412 games
130 C
21.41% · 390 games
131 C
21.41% · 578 games
132 C
21.41% · 313 games
133 C
21.37% · 331 games
134 C
21.31% · 2170 games
135 C
21.29% · 1988 games
136 C
21.27% · 382 games
137 C
21.26% · 917 games
138 C
21.26% · 341 games
139 C
21.26% · 294 games
140 C
21.26% · 988 games
141 C
21.25% · 5450 games
142 C
21.25% · 907 games
143 C
21.23% · 365 games
144 C
21.23% · 252 games
145 C
21.22% · 304 games
146 C
21.21% · 3609 games
147 C
21.2% · 368 games
148 C
21.19% · 420 games
149 C
21.18% · 314 games
150 C
21.17% · 914 games
152 C
21.1% · 680 games
153 C
21.06% · 577 games
154 C
21.05% · 361 games
155 C
21.04% · 1396 games
156 C
21.03% · 976 games
157 C
21.02% · 1829 games
158 C
20.99% · 1409 games
159 C
20.96% · 1108 games
160 C
20.95% · 1086 games
161 C
20.94% · 1085 games
162 C
20.94% · 413 games
163 C
20.94% · 339 games
164 C
20.94% · 683 games
165 C
20.93% · 1082 games
166 C
20.93% · 859 games
167 C
20.91% · 1089 games
168 C
20.91% · 2761 games
169 C
20.88% · 546 games
170 C
20.84% · 956 games
171 C
20.8% · 589 games
172 C
20.77% · 756 games
173 C
20.75% · 1001 games
174 C
20.74% · 1097 games
175 C
20.73% · 844 games
176 C
20.73% · 1182 games
177 C
20.72% · 584 games
178 C
20.7% · 2595 games
179 C
20.69% · 284 games
180 C
20.67% · 433 games
181 C
20.67% · 398 games
182 C
20.63% · 5063 games
183 C
20.6% · 335 games
184 C
20.6% · 1868 games
185 C
20.59% · 720 games
186 C
20.54% · 303 games
187 C
20.54% · 920 games
188 C
20.54% · 997 games
189 C
20.53% · 1159 games
190 C
20.52% · 307 games
191 C
20.52% · 4929 games
192 C
20.46% · 369 games
193 C
20.43% · 2364 games
194 C
20.38% · 1858 games
195 C
20.35% · 2668 games
196 C
20.32% · 406 games
197 C
20.32% · 625 games
198 C
20.31% · 293 games
199 C
20.29% · 616 games
200 C
20.28% · 736 games
201 C
20.27% · 1035 games
202 C
20.26% · 2258 games
203 C
20.25% · 295 games
204 C
20.24% · 252 games
205 C
20.21% · 329 games
206 C
20.21% · 658 games
207 C
20.18% · 815 games
209 C
20.15% · 794 games
210 C
20.15% · 5845 games
211 C
20.14% · 1112 games
212 C
20.11% · 2764 games
213 C
20.1% · 653 games
214 C
20.06% · 390 games
215 C
20.02% · 316 games
216 C
20.01% · 661 games
217 C
20.0% · 2762 games
218 C
19.99% · 804 games
219 C
19.97% · 725 games
220 C
19.95% · 386 games
221 C
19.94% · 385 games
222 C
19.93% · 8958 games
223 C
19.93% · 340 games
225 C
19.9% · 299 games
226 C
19.88% · 943 games
227 C
19.87% · 487 games
228 C
19.79% · 3568 games
229 C
19.78% · 3258 games
230 C
19.78% · 316 games
231 C
19.75% · 367 games
232 C
19.74% · 390 games
233 C
19.73% · 692 games
234 C
19.7% · 2411 games
235 C
19.7% · 806 games
236 C
19.68% · 1038 games
237 C
19.64% · 1133 games
238 C
19.62% · 446 games
239 C
19.61% · 376 games
240 C
19.58% · 424 games
241 C
19.57% · 345 games
242 C
19.55% · 330 games
243 C
19.53% · 265 games
244 C
19.47% · 760 games
246 C
19.44% · 742 games
247 C
19.37% · 262 games
248 C
19.35% · 261 games
249 C
19.32% · 330 games
250 C
19.31% · 1745 games
251 C
19.31% · 325 games
252 C
19.28% · 481 games
253 C
19.28% · 1354 games
254 C
19.27% · 2353 games
255 C
19.24% · 321 games
256 C
19.21% · 2912 games
257 C
19.18% · 348 games
258 C
19.17% · 296 games
259 C
19.15% · 573 games
260 C
19.13% · 1154 games
261 C
19.01% · 497 games
263 C
18.95% · 281 games
264 C
18.94% · 743 games
265 C
18.91% · 431 games
266 C
18.89% · 356 games
267 C
18.88% · 800 games
268 C
18.87% · 465 games
269 C
18.87% · 14025 games
270 C
18.82% · 1189 games
271 C
18.8% · 750 games
272 C
18.79% · 298 games
273 C
18.77% · 277 games
274 C
18.75% · 396 games
275 C
18.75% · 264 games
276 C
18.69% · 1149 games
277 C
18.68% · 447 games
278 C
18.67% · 600 games
279 C
18.61% · 599 games
280 C
18.58% · 1951 games
281 C
18.57% · 638 games
282 C
18.57% · 1482 games
283 C
18.56% · 590 games
284 C
18.54% · 658 games
285 C
18.54% · 352 games
286 C
18.48% · 299 games
287 C
18.47% · 1796 games
288 C
18.47% · 287 games
289 C
18.46% · 348 games
290 C
18.4% · 379 games
291 C
18.38% · 502 games
292 C
18.33% · 885 games
293 C
18.31% · 254 games
294 C
18.28% · 402 games
295 C
18.27% · 1567 games
296 C
18.22% · 675 games
298 C
18.2% · 401 games
299 C
18.19% · 426 games
300 C
18.15% · 2669 games
301 C
18.14% · 397 games
302 C
18.13% · 1802 games
303 C
18.12% · 1029 games
304 C
18.12% · 1736 games
305 C
18.1% · 1555 games
306 C
18.03% · 714 games
307 C
18.03% · 380 games
D
Below 18% Win Rate

D-Tier: Weak Commanders (Below 18% Win Rate)

61
Entries

Winning significantly less than expected.

1 D
17.99% · 389 games
2 D
17.96% · 945 games
3 D
17.96% · 1090 games
4 D
17.95% · 950 games
5 D
17.8% · 295 games
6 D
17.78% · 516 games
7 D
17.71% · 1053 games
8 D
17.7% · 356 games
9 D
17.69% · 1340 games
10 D
17.66% · 899 games
11 D
17.63% · 712 games
12 D
17.58% · 273 games
13 D
17.53% · 559 games
14 D
17.53% · 368 games
15 D
17.48% · 515 games
16 D
17.46% · 305 games
17 D
17.42% · 1277 games
18 D
17.42% · 1022 games
19 D
17.39% · 1222 games
20 D
17.37% · 259 games
21 D
17.32% · 599 games
22 D
17.31% · 3649 games
23 D
17.31% · 299 games
24 D
17.2% · 824 games
25 D
17.02% · 539 games
26 D
17.02% · 2663 games
27 D
16.9% · 914 games
28 D
16.83% · 679 games
29 D
16.79% · 1532 games
30 D
16.78% · 1557 games
31 D
16.77% · 5023 games
32 D
16.72% · 296 games
33 D
16.65% · 871 games
34 D
16.64% · 368 games
35 D
16.63% · 762 games
36 D
16.62% · 1521 games
37 D
16.62% · 486 games
38 D
16.61% · 459 games
39 D
16.45% · 980 games
40 D
16.44% · 327 games
41 D
16.35% · 587 games
42 D
16.2% · 321 games
43 D
15.94% · 461 games
44 D
15.9% · 492 games
45 D
15.35% · 303 games
46 D
15.34% · 1004 games
47 D
15.23% · 1228 games
48 D
15.23% · 2330 games
49 D
15.04% · 452 games
50 D
51 D
14.8% · 953 games
52 D
14.69% · 815 games
53 D
14.49% · 421 games
54 D
14.47% · 2039 games
55 D
14.46% · 363 games
56 D
14.35% · 270 games
57 D
14.31% · 290 games
58 D
14.15% · 258 games
59 D
14.1% · 367 games
60 D
12.56% · 675 games
61 D
10.8% · 324 games
FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

How is the Playgroup.gg Commander tier list calculated?

Every commander with at least 250 tracked games and at least 10 distinct registered pilots across all tracked Commander games is ranked by normalized win rate. Win rates are adjusted to a 4-player baseline (25% expected) so a win in a 2-player game and a win in a 5-player game are weighted fairly. Commanders scoring 35% or more are S-tier; 30-35% are A-tier; 23-30% are B-tier; 18-23% are C-tier; and below 18% are D-tier.

What does each tier mean?

S-tier commanders win roughly 40% more games than expected. A-tier wins about 20-40% above expected. B-tier is near the statistical baseline. C-tier is below average. D-tier commanders score below 18%, significantly under the 25% baseline. All values are normalized across pod sizes.

How often is the Commander tier list updated?

The data refreshes every 6 hours and is based on all tracked games to date.

Why is my commander not on the tier list?

A commander needs at least 250 tracked games across all tracked Commander games, and those games must come from at least 10 different registered pilots. The pilot diversity floor stops a single playgroup or grinder from skewing the ranking with their pet deck. You can still see all-time stats on any commander's individual page.

How is this different from EDHREC rankings or other tier lists?

EDHREC ranks by deck popularity, counting how many people register a commander. Other tier lists like Draftsim are based on editorial opinion. Playgroup.gg ranks by actual game win rates across thousands of casual Commander games tracked through the Playgroup.gg app and Playgroup Live each month.