Data-Backed · Win Rates

Commander Tier List

Playgroup.gg ranks 1233 commanders into five tiers by win rate across 594,601 tracked casual Commander games from the all time. The first Commander tier list based on real gameplay data, not opinions or deck registrations.

As of July 2026, the top Commanders by win rate are Hidetsugu and Kairi (48.49%), Narset, Enlightened Master (41.3%), and Rhoda, Geist Avenger (39.72%), from 594,601 tracked games.

1,233
Ranked
594,601
Games
Methodology
Last Updated

Tiers are assigned by win rate across all tracked Commander games. Win rates are normalized to a 4-player baseline (25% expected) so games with different pod sizes are weighted fairly. A commander needs at least 250 tracked games to qualify, and those games must come from at least 10 distinct registered pilots so a single playgroup cannot dominate the ranking. Data comes from games recorded playing paper magic through the Playgroup.gg app and online games played with Playgroup Live. Win rates are calculated from both registered-deck and guest-commander participations.

S 35%+ Win Rate
A 30-35% Win Rate
B 23-30% Win Rate
C 18-23% Win Rate
D Below 18% Win Rate
S
35%+ Win Rate

S-Tier: Dominant Commanders (35%+ Win Rate)

32
Entries

Winning 40% more often than expected in 4-player pods.

1 S
48.49% · 446 games
2 S
41.3% · 1528 games
3 S
39.72% · 377 games
4 S
39.68% · 373 games
5 S
39.26% · 256 games
6 S
39.21% · 744 games
8 S
38.73% · 497 games
9 S
38.53% · 811 games
10 S
38.47% · 258 games
11 S
38.14% · 649 games
12 S
37.73% · 986 games
13 S
37.44% · 2933 games
14 S
37.16% · 333 games
16 S
36.72% · 638 games
17 S
36.55% · 394 games
18 S
20 S
36.09% · 489 games
21 S
35.99% · 2097 games
22 S
35.98% · 779 games
23 S
35.82% · 552 games
24 S
35.78% · 480 games
25 S
35.76% · 660 games
26 S
35.69% · 283 games
27 S
35.62% · 1490 games
28 S
29 S
35.6% · 2206 games
30 S
35.56% · 869 games
31 S
35.27% · 757 games
32 S
35.01% · 2386 games
A
30-35% Win Rate

A-Tier: Strong Commanders (30-35% Win Rate)

165
Entries

Consistently above the 25% expected baseline.

2 A
34.91% · 328 games
3 A
34.81% · 4525 games
4 A
34.7% · 3491 games
5 A
34.62% · 850 games
6 A
34.45% · 770 games
7 A
34.43% · 1675 games
8 A
34.42% · 252 games
9 A
34.25% · 1519 games
10 A
34.19% · 408 games
11 A
33.99% · 1700 games
12 A
33.95% · 352 games
13 A
33.94% · 621 games
14 A
33.93% · 252 games
16 A
33.8% · 1003 games
17 A
33.73% · 8594 games
18 A
33.66% · 303 games
19 A
33.63% · 1868 games
20 A
33.54% · 735 games
21 A
33.52% · 320 games
22 A
33.46% · 396 games
23 A
33.45% · 5315 games
24 A
33.42% · 285 games
25 A
33.33% · 711 games
26 A
33.32% · 2856 games
27 A
33.22% · 1076 games
29 A
33.13% · 2232 games
30 A
33.11% · 333 games
31 A
33.06% · 3360 games
32 A
32.96% · 678 games
33 A
32.94% · 3777 games
34 A
32.85% · 468 games
35 A
32.84% · 252 games
36 A
32.77% · 1013 games
37 A
32.7% · 315 games
38 A
32.69% · 387 games
39 A
32.64% · 494 games
40 A
32.62% · 489 games
41 A
32.61% · 825 games
42 A
32.59% · 4660 games
43 A
32.58% · 597 games
44 A
32.56% · 1534 games
45 A
32.55% · 1904 games
46 A
32.53% · 3822 games
47 A
32.49% · 774 games
48 A
32.46% · 412 games
49 A
32.45% · 282 games
50 A
32.38% · 630 games
51 A
32.38% · 627 games
52 A
32.36% · 683 games
53 A
32.27% · 1375 games
54 A
32.26% · 1067 games
55 A
32.24% · 525 games
56 A
32.22% · 398 games
57 A
32.13% · 368 games
58 A
32.11% · 1826 games
59 A
32.1% · 3597 games
60 A
32.09% · 1132 games
61 A
32.07% · 1739 games
62 A
32.03% · 519 games
63 A
32.01% · 1502 games
64 A
32.0% · 268 games
66 A
31.95% · 1519 games
67 A
31.92% · 7421 games
68 A
31.88% · 6188 games
69 A
31.83% · 1054 games
70 A
31.82% · 253 games
71 A
31.81% · 334 games
72 A
31.73% · 2231 games
73 A
31.72% · 1329 games
74 A
31.71% · 350 games
75 A
31.65% · 1281 games
76 A
31.65% · 665 games
77 A
31.63% · 837 games
78 A
31.62% · 291 games
79 A
31.61% · 1682 games
80 A
31.6% · 549 games
81 A
31.57% · 974 games
82 A
31.56% · 1166 games
83 A
31.51% · 1724 games
84 A
31.5% · 5303 games
85 A
31.49% · 597 games
86 A
31.45% · 384 games
87 A
31.43% · 4601 games
88 A
31.42% · 2898 games
89 A
31.4% · 730 games
90 A
31.37% · 651 games
91 A
31.35% · 386 games
92 A
31.34% · 1766 games
93 A
31.32% · 2417 games
94 A
31.3% · 389 games
95 A
31.28% · 3139 games
96 A
31.28% · 4875 games
97 A
31.27% · 2336 games
98 A
31.25% · 328 games
99 A
31.25% · 380 games
100 A
31.22% · 8940 games
101 A
31.21% · 503 games
102 A
31.19% · 331 games
103 A
31.19% · 1833 games
104 A
31.12% · 2294 games
105 A
31.08% · 930 games
106 A
31.07% · 1537 games
107 A
31.04% · 932 games
108 A
31.0% · 271 games
109 A
30.94% · 1413 games
110 A
30.9% · 1726 games
111 A
30.88% · 3146 games
112 A
30.88% · 3637 games
113 A
30.86% · 747 games
114 A
30.84% · 1506 games
115 A
30.83% · 712 games
116 A
30.82% · 1773 games
117 A
30.8% · 827 games
118 A
30.79% · 259 games
119 A
30.76% · 2199 games
120 A
30.75% · 1248 games
121 A
30.72% · 616 games
124 A
30.66% · 711 games
125 A
30.65% · 1901 games
126 A
30.6% · 1858 games
128 A
30.58% · 2097 games
129 A
30.56% · 279 games
130 A
30.55% · 590 games
131 A
30.55% · 401 games
132 A
30.55% · 1672 games
133 A
30.52% · 281 games
134 A
30.47% · 297 games
135 A
30.46% · 2782 games
136 A
30.46% · 2252 games
137 A
30.42% · 1378 games
138 A
30.4% · 551 games
140 A
30.35% · 1351 games
141 A
30.34% · 407 games
142 A
30.34% · 393 games
143 A
30.33% · 3196 games
144 A
30.32% · 601 games
145 A
30.31% · 889 games
146 A
30.28% · 317 games
147 A
30.26% · 831 games
148 A
30.26% · 14467 games
149 A
30.21% · 1141 games
150 A
30.21% · 2764 games
151 A
30.2% · 610 games
152 A
30.15% · 2134 games
153 A
30.13% · 1349 games
154 A
30.13% · 1544 games
155 A
30.13% · 994 games
156 A
30.11% · 2787 games
157 A
30.1% · 8283 games
158 A
30.09% · 2143 games
159 A
30.08% · 6790 games
160 A
30.06% · 3495 games
161 A
30.06% · 390 games
162 A
30.06% · 11548 games
163 A
30.05% · 1450 games
165 A
30.02% · 603 games
B
23-30% Win Rate

B-Tier: Average Commanders (23-30% Win Rate)

664
Entries

Near the expected win rate for 4-player Commander.

1 B
29.99% · 1768 games
2 B
29.97% · 1052 games
3 B
29.94% · 1945 games
4 B
29.87% · 7766 games
5 B
29.87% · 4472 games
7 B
29.83% · 3911 games
8 B
29.79% · 747 games
9 B
29.77% · 1368 games
10 B
29.77% · 257 games
11 B
29.77% · 1490 games
12 B
29.76% · 1254 games
13 B
29.76% · 8949 games
14 B
29.74% · 1166 games
15 B
29.72% · 344 games
16 B
29.72% · 307 games
17 B
29.72% · 12263 games
18 B
29.72% · 4682 games
19 B
29.69% · 778 games
20 B
29.68% · 774 games
21 B
29.62% · 260 games
22 B
29.61% · 781 games
23 B
29.6% · 2535 games
25 B
29.57% · 443 games
26 B
29.55% · 4143 games
27 B
29.54% · 831 games
28 B
29.54% · 1651 games
29 B
29.53% · 817 games
30 B
29.52% · 757 games
31 B
29.52% · 3215 games
32 B
29.52% · 1721 games
34 B
29.5% · 1173 games
35 B
29.49% · 1783 games
36 B
29.48% · 262 games
37 B
29.48% · 1383 games
38 B
29.43% · 1388 games
39 B
29.41% · 1446 games
40 B
29.41% · 380 games
41 B
29.41% · 7939 games
42 B
29.37% · 933 games
43 B
29.37% · 5965 games
44 B
29.36% · 1054 games
45 B
29.36% · 1163 games
46 B
29.35% · 460 games
47 B
29.32% · 961 games
48 B
29.31% · 3462 games
49 B
29.31% · 1415 games
50 B
29.31% · 789 games
51 B
29.3% · 2506 games
52 B
29.28% · 1093 games
53 B
29.27% · 731 games
54 B
29.25% · 3962 games
55 B
29.25% · 1142 games
56 B
29.24% · 2158 games
57 B
29.23% · 378 games
58 B
29.22% · 456 games
59 B
29.21% · 5716 games
60 B
29.18% · 269 games
61 B
29.17% · 1230 games
62 B
29.13% · 357 games
64 B
29.01% · 2860 games
65 B
28.99% · 1090 games
66 B
28.97% · 876 games
67 B
28.96% · 3065 games
68 B
28.93% · 3138 games
69 B
28.93% · 17790 games
70 B
28.9% · 372 games
71 B
28.88% · 432 games
72 B
28.87% · 2164 games
73 B
28.87% · 957 games
74 B
28.85% · 2030 games
75 B
28.85% · 2466 games
76 B
28.84% · 508 games
77 B
28.81% · 289 games
78 B
28.79% · 554 games
79 B
28.78% · 880 games
80 B
28.77% · 683 games
81 B
28.75% · 2378 games
82 B
28.74% · 508 games
83 B
28.74% · 3665 games
84 B
28.73% · 315 games
85 B
28.72% · 1506 games
86 B
28.72% · 565 games
87 B
28.69% · 569 games
88 B
28.67% · 579 games
89 B
28.67% · 341 games
90 B
28.66% · 696 games
91 B
28.66% · 540 games
92 B
28.63% · 1696 games
93 B
28.62% · 304 games
94 B
28.59% · 8098 games
95 B
28.57% · 1056 games
96 B
28.57% · 1311 games
97 B
28.56% · 2282 games
98 B
28.54% · 2267 games
99 B
28.54% · 869 games
100 B
28.54% · 417 games
101 B
28.52% · 497 games
102 B
28.5% · 5879 games
103 B
28.46% · 549 games
104 B
28.46% · 340 games
105 B
28.45% · 565 games
106 B
28.42% · 4230 games
107 B
28.39% · 1194 games
108 B
28.39% · 2031 games
109 B
28.37% · 504 games
110 B
28.35% · 1255 games
111 B
28.33% · 2801 games
112 B
28.3% · 10988 games
113 B
28.28% · 2934 games
114 B
28.26% · 376 games
115 B
28.26% · 2095 games
116 B
28.21% · 257 games
117 B
28.17% · 2756 games
118 B
28.15% · 1420 games
119 B
28.15% · 595 games
120 B
28.14% · 4420 games
121 B
28.13% · 2813 games
122 B
28.13% · 280 games
123 B
28.12% · 914 games
124 B
28.11% · 522 games
125 B
28.1% · 589 games
126 B
28.09% · 1424 games
127 B
28.09% · 5655 games
128 B
28.08% · 2060 games
129 B
28.06% · 465 games
130 B
28.06% · 703 games
131 B
28.05% · 1049 games
132 B
133 B
28.01% · 929 games
134 B
28.01% · 3394 games
135 B
28.0% · 383 games
136 B
27.99% · 2158 games
137 B
27.98% · 1537 games
138 B
27.95% · 728 games
139 B
27.95% · 6249 games
140 B
27.94% · 832 games
142 B
27.94% · 4639 games
143 B
27.94% · 528 games
144 B
27.93% · 2246 games
145 B
27.91% · 395 games
146 B
27.89% · 649 games
147 B
27.89% · 251 games
148 B
27.88% · 1378 games
149 B
27.88% · 5464 games
150 B
27.88% · 643 games
151 B
27.86% · 559 games
152 B
27.84% · 545 games
153 B
27.82% · 2813 games
155 B
27.79% · 1236 games
156 B
27.78% · 521 games
157 B
27.78% · 576 games
158 B
27.77% · 1211 games
159 B
27.76% · 1113 games
160 B
27.76% · 2328 games
161 B
27.74% · 3320 games
162 B
27.73% · 8193 games
163 B
27.73% · 311 games
164 B
27.72% · 6808 games
166 B
27.72% · 294 games
167 B
27.72% · 827 games
168 B
27.71% · 536 games
169 B
27.7% · 5147 games
170 B
27.69% · 455 games
171 B
27.69% · 753 games
172 B
27.67% · 1594 games
173 B
174 B
27.65% · 641 games
175 B
27.64% · 435 games
176 B
27.64% · 577 games
177 B
27.64% · 1802 games
178 B
27.64% · 5341 games
179 B
27.61% · 2029 games
180 B
27.6% · 1478 games
181 B
27.59% · 512 games
182 B
27.58% · 5119 games
183 B
27.55% · 2249 games
184 B
27.51% · 2482 games
185 B
27.51% · 708 games
186 B
27.5% · 8045 games
187 B
27.5% · 740 games
188 B
27.49% · 1045 games
189 B
190 B
27.48% · 926 games
191 B
27.48% · 5846 games
192 B
27.47% · 446 games
193 B
27.44% · 256 games
194 B
27.44% · 297 games
195 B
27.44% · 513 games
196 B
27.4% · 3740 games
197 B
27.4% · 1220 games
198 B
27.4% · 605 games
199 B
27.39% · 773 games
200 B
27.37% · 2629 games
201 B
27.37% · 528 games
202 B
27.36% · 370 games
203 B
27.34% · 374 games
204 B
27.32% · 1660 games
205 B
27.31% · 574 games
206 B
27.3% · 814 games
207 B
27.3% · 543 games
208 B
27.3% · 500 games
209 B
27.29% · 634 games
210 B
27.26% · 831 games
211 B
27.25% · 944 games
212 B
27.24% · 681 games
213 B
27.23% · 1906 games
214 B
27.23% · 8132 games
215 B
27.2% · 295 games
216 B
27.19% · 262 games
217 B
27.19% · 400 games
218 B
27.18% · 2034 games
219 B
27.13% · 2343 games
220 B
221 B
27.12% · 319 games
222 B
27.1% · 429 games
225 B
27.09% · 1030 games
226 B
27.08% · 936 games
227 B
27.05% · 633 games
228 B
27.05% · 941 games
229 B
27.02% · 495 games
230 B
27.02% · 322 games
231 B
27.01% · 2125 games
232 B
27.01% · 934 games
233 B
27.0% · 2270 games
234 B
26.99% · 677 games
235 B
26.99% · 615 games
236 B
26.97% · 748 games
237 B
26.96% · 8437 games
238 B
26.94% · 1699 games
239 B
26.93% · 842 games
240 B
26.93% · 765 games
241 B
26.92% · 274 games
242 B
26.91% · 498 games
243 B
26.9% · 1483 games
244 B
26.88% · 398 games
245 B
26.88% · 332 games
246 B
26.88% · 1596 games
247 B
26.87% · 374 games
248 B
26.86% · 9471 games
249 B
26.85% · 4291 games
250 B
26.84% · 599 games
251 B
26.83% · 259 games
252 B
26.83% · 668 games
253 B
26.83% · 805 games
254 B
26.82% · 1454 games
255 B
26.8% · 918 games
256 B
26.79% · 2858 games
257 B
26.79% · 8439 games
258 B
26.79% · 782 games
259 B
26.79% · 4148 games
260 B
26.77% · 4004 games
261 B
26.77% · 790 games
262 B
26.77% · 410 games
263 B
26.76% · 427 games
264 B
26.75% · 1197 games
265 B
26.75% · 9748 games
266 B
26.74% · 2293 games
267 B
26.74% · 258 games
268 B
26.71% · 4978 games
269 B
26.7% · 15066 games
270 B
26.7% · 544 games
271 B
26.69% · 518 games
272 B
26.67% · 1156 games
273 B
26.66% · 856 games
274 B
26.65% · 1149 games
275 B
26.65% · 10746 games
276 B
26.63% · 1224 games
277 B
26.63% · 628 games
278 B
26.63% · 645 games
279 B
26.61% · 358 games
280 B
26.59% · 1553 games
281 B
26.57% · 1273 games
282 B
26.53% · 766 games
283 B
26.53% · 8971 games
284 B
26.52% · 1863 games
285 B
26.5% · 1200 games
286 B
26.5% · 250 games
287 B
26.5% · 3288 games
288 B
26.47% · 3732 games
289 B
26.47% · 5152 games
290 B
26.47% · 835 games
291 B
26.46% · 394 games
292 B
26.42% · 2426 games
293 B
26.42% · 879 games
294 B
26.42% · 724 games
296 B
26.38% · 705 games
297 B
26.38% · 416 games
298 B
26.38% · 761 games
299 B
26.38% · 2175 games
300 B
26.37% · 729 games
301 B
26.36% · 348 games
302 B
26.33% · 1162 games
303 B
26.33% · 338 games
304 B
26.33% · 452 games
305 B
26.32% · 2100 games
306 B
26.29% · 12485 games
307 B
26.28% · 490 games
308 B
26.26% · 633 games
309 B
26.26% · 2042 games
310 B
26.26% · 1312 games
311 B
26.24% · 403 games
312 B
26.23% · 4172 games
313 B
26.23% · 2203 games
314 B
26.22% · 348 games
315 B
26.22% · 3103 games
316 B
26.21% · 495 games
317 B
26.21% · 1551 games
318 B
26.19% · 293 games
319 B
26.15% · 392 games
320 B
26.14% · 284 games
321 B
26.14% · 1596 games
322 B
26.13% · 4668 games
323 B
26.11% · 3643 games
324 B
26.11% · 316 games
325 B
326 B
327 B
26.1% · 9957 games
328 B
26.09% · 253 games
329 B
26.08% · 4361 games
330 B
26.07% · 676 games
331 B
26.07% · 2169 games
332 B
26.06% · 7617 games
333 B
26.06% · 377 games
334 B
26.06% · 283 games
335 B
26.06% · 260 games
336 B
26.03% · 339 games
337 B
26.03% · 1142 games
338 B
26.03% · 13441 games
339 B
26.02% · 879 games
340 B
26.02% · 2700 games
341 B
26.01% · 371 games
342 B
26.01% · 894 games
343 B
25.98% · 9486 games
344 B
25.98% · 280 games
346 B
25.97% · 3309 games
347 B
25.97% · 5982 games
348 B
25.97% · 411 games
349 B
25.88% · 596 games
350 B
25.88% · 426 games
351 B
25.87% · 575 games
352 B
25.86% · 465 games
353 B
25.86% · 4407 games
355 B
25.85% · 410 games
356 B
25.83% · 1117 games
357 B
25.82% · 366 games
358 B
25.81% · 803 games
359 B
25.8% · 1554 games
360 B
25.78% · 415 games
361 B
25.77% · 620 games
363 B
25.74% · 677 games
365 B
25.7% · 498 games
366 B
25.69% · 544 games
367 B
25.68% · 1170 games
368 B
25.68% · 773 games
369 B
25.67% · 1199 games
370 B
25.66% · 301 games
371 B
25.66% · 832 games
372 B
25.65% · 4598 games
373 B
25.65% · 1383 games
374 B
25.65% · 270 games
375 B
25.65% · 579 games
376 B
25.64% · 621 games
377 B
25.64% · 468 games
378 B
25.64% · 471 games
379 B
25.62% · 5361 games
380 B
25.62% · 481 games
381 B
25.62% · 772 games
382 B
25.6% · 331 games
383 B
25.6% · 1160 games
384 B
25.6% · 2465 games
385 B
25.59% · 1684 games
386 B
25.59% · 1573 games
387 B
25.58% · 1156 games
388 B
25.58% · 387 games
390 B
25.57% · 2222 games
391 B
25.56% · 1612 games
392 B
25.53% · 1278 games
393 B
25.49% · 1490 games
394 B
25.49% · 1185 games
395 B
25.48% · 2040 games
396 B
25.47% · 1591 games
397 B
25.45% · 13978 games
398 B
25.43% · 11811 games
399 B
25.42% · 1023 games
400 B
25.41% · 485 games
401 B
25.38% · 3008 games
402 B
25.38% · 262 games
403 B
25.38% · 8739 games
404 B
25.38% · 1193 games
405 B
25.37% · 819 games
406 B
25.36% · 276 games
407 B
25.34% · 4584 games
408 B
25.32% · 1002 games
409 B
25.32% · 2419 games
410 B
25.32% · 549 games
411 B
25.31% · 1749 games
412 B
25.3% · 1006 games
413 B
25.3% · 759 games
414 B
25.27% · 839 games
415 B
25.27% · 2156 games
416 B
25.26% · 285 games
417 B
25.26% · 1645 games
418 B
25.25% · 1835 games
419 B
25.23% · 1294 games
420 B
25.22% · 907 games
421 B
25.22% · 4782 games
422 B
25.15% · 1539 games
423 B
25.1% · 2447 games
424 B
425 B
25.09% · 547 games
426 B
25.07% · 382 games
427 B
25.03% · 5292 games
428 B
25.02% · 2031 games
429 B
25.0% · 430 games
431 B
25.0% · 398 games
432 B
24.99% · 5984 games
433 B
24.98% · 4219 games
434 B
24.97% · 968 games
435 B
24.97% · 754 games
436 B
24.95% · 3694 games
438 B
24.94% · 1701 games
439 B
24.93% · 758 games
440 B
24.91% · 282 games
441 B
24.9% · 1283 games
442 B
24.9% · 504 games
443 B
24.9% · 496 games
444 B
24.89% · 932 games
445 B
24.89% · 1134 games
446 B
24.88% · 433 games
447 B
24.88% · 821 games
448 B
24.87% · 2341 games
449 B
24.87% · 572 games
450 B
24.86% · 345 games
451 B
24.85% · 510 games
452 B
24.84% · 322 games
453 B
24.84% · 309 games
454 B
24.84% · 460 games
455 B
24.82% · 1280 games
456 B
24.81% · 2541 games
457 B
24.8% · 1986 games
458 B
24.8% · 1710 games
459 B
24.79% · 836 games
460 B
24.79% · 1183 games
461 B
24.79% · 2331 games
462 B
24.78% · 7041 games
463 B
24.77% · 11256 games
465 B
24.76% · 6030 games
466 B
24.75% · 1619 games
467 B
24.75% · 598 games
468 B
24.75% · 495 games
469 B
24.74% · 284 games
470 B
24.73% · 1696 games
471 B
24.73% · 1777 games
472 B
24.73% · 653 games
473 B
24.72% · 4952 games
474 B
24.72% · 616 games
475 B
Six
24.7% · 412 games
476 B
24.69% · 12321 games
477 B
24.63% · 6696 games
478 B
24.63% · 677 games
479 B
24.63% · 3360 games
480 B
24.62% · 399 games
481 B
24.62% · 465 games
482 B
24.6% · 750 games
483 B
24.57% · 1342 games
484 B
24.56% · 8830 games
485 B
24.53% · 7918 games
486 B
24.52% · 788 games
487 B
24.51% · 255 games
488 B
24.51% · 253 games
489 B
24.5% · 348 games
490 B
24.46% · 1574 games
491 B
24.46% · 555 games
492 B
24.46% · 8120 games
493 B
24.45% · 3831 games
494 B
24.45% · 3095 games
495 B
24.45% · 680 games
496 B
24.44% · 1621 games
497 B
24.44% · 270 games
498 B
24.44% · 534 games
499 B
24.43% · 522 games
500 B
24.41% · 1105 games
501 B
24.4% · 504 games
502 B
24.4% · 1041 games
503 B
24.4% · 414 games
504 B
24.39% · 1464 games
505 B
24.37% · 2425 games
506 B
24.37% · 4098 games
507 B
24.35% · 1877 games
508 B
24.34% · 267 games
509 B
24.34% · 1676 games
510 B
24.34% · 1063 games
511 B
24.33% · 1653 games
512 B
24.31% · 1017 games
513 B
24.3% · 359 games
514 B
24.3% · 1425 games
515 B
24.29% · 563 games
516 B
24.27% · 3619 games
517 B
24.27% · 1204 games
518 B
24.25% · 701 games
519 B
24.25% · 2602 games
520 B
24.23% · 1360 games
521 B
24.23% · 517 games
522 B
24.22% · 322 games
523 B
24.21% · 379 games
525 B
24.19% · 371 games
526 B
24.18% · 1286 games
527 B
24.18% · 1495 games
528 B
24.17% · 1030 games
529 B
24.16% · 1372 games
531 B
24.16% · 326 games
532 B
24.15% · 440 games
533 B
24.15% · 1813 games
534 B
24.14% · 583 games
535 B
24.14% · 4749 games
536 B
24.12% · 512 games
537 B
24.11% · 450 games
538 B
24.1% · 474 games
539 B
24.1% · 444 games
540 B
24.09% · 771 games
541 B
24.09% · 1702 games
542 B
24.07% · 1430 games
543 B
24.06% · 1575 games
544 B
24.04% · 1773 games
545 B
24.04% · 546 games
546 B
24.04% · 830 games
547 B
24.01% · 352 games
548 B
24.0% · 9206 games
549 B
23.98% · 6571 games
550 B
23.97% · 317 games
551 B
23.97% · 898 games
552 B
23.96% · 289 games
553 B
23.96% · 4282 games
554 B
23.96% · 1269 games
555 B
23.95% · 810 games
556 B
23.92% · 3709 games
557 B
23.91% · 253 games
558 B
23.91% · 366 games
559 B
23.9% · 1001 games
560 B
23.9% · 432 games
561 B
23.89% · 1199 games
562 B
23.89% · 429 games
563 B
23.89% · 5315 games
564 B
23.88% · 824 games
565 B
23.86% · 1355 games
566 B
23.84% · 453 games
567 B
23.83% · 7713 games
568 B
23.82% · 2232 games
569 B
23.82% · 1163 games
570 B
23.81% · 378 games
571 B
23.8% · 1123 games
572 B
23.79% · 1202 games
573 B
23.78% · 471 games
574 B
23.78% · 1085 games
575 B
23.77% · 649 games
576 B
23.77% · 2694 games
577 B
23.75% · 560 games
578 B
23.75% · 500 games
579 B
23.74% · 458 games
580 B
23.73% · 1477 games
581 B
23.73% · 315 games
582 B
23.73% · 1652 games
583 B
23.72% · 6202 games
584 B
23.71% · 836 games
585 B
23.71% · 4080 games
586 B
23.71% · 948 games
587 B
23.71% · 464 games
588 B
23.69% · 896 games
589 B
23.69% · 4060 games
590 B
23.68% · 567 games
591 B
23.67% · 358 games
592 B
23.65% · 260 games
593 B
23.65% · 852 games
594 B
23.64% · 313 games
595 B
23.62% · 363 games
596 B
23.62% · 290 games
597 B
23.61% · 937 games
598 B
23.6% · 608 games
599 B
23.58% · 848 games
600 B
23.58% · 1551 games
601 B
23.58% · 1828 games
602 B
23.57% · 333 games
603 B
23.56% · 608 games
604 B
23.56% · 277 games
605 B
23.55% · 1070 games
606 B
23.54% · 549 games
607 B
23.54% · 720 games
608 B
23.54% · 856 games
609 B
23.54% · 291 games
610 B
23.52% · 881 games
611 B
23.52% · 777 games
612 B
23.49% · 381 games
613 B
23.48% · 903 games
614 B
23.47% · 754 games
615 B
23.47% · 2852 games
616 B
23.47% · 964 games
617 B
23.44% · 2049 games
618 B
23.43% · 683 games
619 B
23.41% · 408 games
620 B
23.4% · 1081 games
621 B
23.39% · 1348 games
622 B
23.37% · 415 games
623 B
23.34% · 888 games
624 B
23.32% · 1506 games
625 B
23.32% · 759 games
626 B
23.29% · 761 games
627 B
23.28% · 335 games
628 B
23.28% · 2474 games
629 B
23.28% · 464 games
630 B
23.27% · 449 games
631 B
23.27% · 420 games
632 B
23.27% · 983 games
633 B
23.26% · 273 games
635 B
23.26% · 301 games
636 B
23.25% · 342 games
637 B
23.24% · 370 games
638 B
23.24% · 1192 games
639 B
23.23% · 1989 games
640 B
23.22% · 267 games
641 B
23.2% · 487 games
642 B
23.18% · 3926 games
643 B
23.17% · 872 games
644 B
645 B
23.14% · 404 games
646 B
23.14% · 255 games
647 B
23.13% · 1403 games
648 B
23.12% · 3112 games
649 B
23.11% · 1419 games
650 B
23.09% · 748 games
651 B
23.09% · 627 games
652 B
23.09% · 457 games
653 B
23.08% · 5319 games
654 B
23.08% · 859 games
655 B
23.08% · 2861 games
656 B
23.07% · 376 games
657 B
23.07% · 349 games
658 B
23.06% · 903 games
659 B
23.06% · 1093 games
660 B
23.04% · 600 games
661 B
23.03% · 2204 games
662 B
23.02% · 695 games
663 B
23.02% · 7372 games
664 B
23.0% · 8053 games
C
18-23% Win Rate

C-Tier: Below Average Commanders (18-23% Win Rate)

309
Entries

Underperforming the statistical baseline.

1 C
22.99% · 274 games
2 C
22.98% · 918 games
3 C
22.97% · 2822 games
4 C
22.96% · 577 games
5 C
22.96% · 3130 games
6 C
22.95% · 1745 games
7 C
22.94% · 896 games
8 C
22.93% · 2821 games
9 C
22.92% · 264 games
10 C
22.92% · 1943 games
11 C
22.9% · 286 games
12 C
22.9% · 262 games
13 C
22.9% · 583 games
14 C
22.9% · 1402 games
15 C
22.89% · 1247 games
16 C
22.85% · 1024 games
17 C
22.85% · 954 games
18 C
22.84% · 533 games
19 C
22.84% · 984 games
20 C
22.84% · 1851 games
21 C
22.82% · 608 games
22 C
22.82% · 3162 games
23 C
22.78% · 1049 games
24 C
22.76% · 805 games
25 C
22.76% · 2235 games
26 C
22.76% · 715 games
27 C
22.76% · 1014 games
28 C
22.75% · 389 games
29 C
22.73% · 880 games
30 C
22.73% · 726 games
32 C
22.72% · 263 games
33 C
22.71% · 1364 games
34 C
22.71% · 523 games
35 C
22.69% · 1735 games
36 C
22.69% · 821 games
37 C
22.67% · 1515 games
39 C
22.64% · 795 games
40 C
22.61% · 1862 games
41 C
22.58% · 1676 games
42 C
22.58% · 3464 games
43 C
22.57% · 3009 games
44 C
22.57% · 886 games
45 C
22.53% · 1256 games
46 C
22.5% · 5778 games
47 C
22.48% · 318 games
48 C
22.48% · 1964 games
49 C
22.46% · 345 games
50 C
22.44% · 1398 games
51 C
22.43% · 1613 games
52 C
22.42% · 2228 games
53 C
22.42% · 1113 games
54 C
22.42% · 648 games
55 C
22.4% · 2137 games
56 C
22.4% · 2289 games
57 C
22.4% · 519 games
58 C
22.39% · 2729 games
59 C
22.37% · 380 games
60 C
22.35% · 5943 games
61 C
22.32% · 4242 games
62 C
22.31% · 334 games
63 C
22.29% · 793 games
64 C
22.25% · 1047 games
65 C
22.25% · 391 games
66 C
22.25% · 891 games
67 C
22.24% · 353 games
68 C
22.24% · 380 games
69 C
22.21% · 924 games
70 C
22.2% · 268 games
71 C
22.17% · 5356 games
72 C
22.16% · 387 games
73 C
22.15% · 984 games
74 C
22.14% · 516 games
75 C
22.11% · 303 games
77 C
22.1% · 3730 games
78 C
22.09% · 490 games
79 C
22.09% · 464 games
80 C
22.09% · 3221 games
81 C
22.06% · 910 games
82 C
22.04% · 313 games
83 C
22.02% · 361 games
84 C
22.0% · 484 games
85 C
21.98% · 364 games
86 C
21.97% · 726 games
87 C
21.96% · 3045 games
88 C
21.96% · 312 games
89 C
21.95% · 500 games
90 C
21.94% · 1414 games
91 C
21.94% · 727 games
92 C
21.92% · 527 games
93 C
21.89% · 346 games
94 C
21.89% · 610 games
95 C
21.86% · 797 games
96 C
21.83% · 1215 games
97 C
21.82% · 433 games
98 C
21.82% · 275 games
99 C
21.79% · 647 games
100 C
21.78% · 1474 games
101 C
21.76% · 2446 games
102 C
21.76% · 2592 games
103 C
21.76% · 4711 games
104 C
21.72% · 305 games
105 C
21.72% · 762 games
106 C
21.68% · 384 games
107 C
21.67% · 1209 games
108 C
21.65% · 3150 games
109 C
21.64% · 952 games
110 C
21.63% · 2523 games
111 C
21.61% · 2843 games
112 C
21.59% · 337 games
113 C
21.56% · 262 games
114 C
21.51% · 408 games
115 C
21.51% · 2003 games
116 C
21.5% · 371 games
117 C
21.49% · 2739 games
118 C
21.49% · 1074 games
119 C
21.47% · 893 games
120 C
21.47% · 1119 games
121 C
21.47% · 998 games
122 C
21.45% · 1219 games
123 C
21.43% · 2071 games
124 C
21.41% · 1171 games
125 C
21.39% · 665 games
126 C
21.39% · 2035 games
127 C
21.39% · 1142 games
128 C
21.35% · 3771 games
129 C
21.34% · 499 games
130 C
21.33% · 279 games
131 C
21.31% · 711 games
132 C
21.26% · 915 games
133 C
21.24% · 5731 games
134 C
21.24% · 651 games
135 C
21.2% · 329 games
136 C
21.19% · 2278 games
137 C
21.17% · 1013 games
138 C
21.17% · 2004 games
139 C
21.14% · 376 games
140 C
21.12% · 348 games
141 C
21.12% · 367 games
142 C
21.11% · 804 games
144 C
21.1% · 372 games
145 C
21.1% · 474 games
146 C
21.09% · 1446 games
147 C
21.07% · 414 games
148 C
21.07% · 1031 games
149 C
21.07% · 1037 games
150 C
21.07% · 305 games
151 C
21.04% · 347 games
152 C
21.01% · 1907 games
153 C
21.01% · 376 games
154 C
21.0% · 344 games
155 C
20.98% · 255 games
156 C
20.97% · 341 games
157 C
20.97% · 310 games
158 C
20.96% · 656 games
159 C
20.95% · 2873 games
160 C
20.95% · 463 games
161 C
20.94% · 954 games
162 C
20.93% · 2743 games
163 C
20.89% · 657 games
164 C
20.88% · 370 games
165 C
20.88% · 1122 games
166 C
20.84% · 1022 games
167 C
20.81% · 615 games
168 C
20.8% · 619 games
169 C
20.79% · 309 games
170 C
20.79% · 796 games
171 C
20.77% · 763 games
172 C
20.75% · 1130 games
173 C
20.74% · 944 games
174 C
20.73% · 1158 games
175 C
20.7% · 355 games
176 C
20.69% · 650 games
177 C
20.67% · 900 games
178 C
20.67% · 1217 games
179 C
20.66% · 725 games
180 C
20.65% · 2492 games
181 C
20.64% · 1452 games
182 C
20.62% · 331 games
183 C
20.61% · 1013 games
184 C
20.58% · 385 games
185 C
20.58% · 2824 games
186 C
20.58% · 605 games
187 C
20.56% · 1037 games
188 C
20.54% · 314 games
189 C
20.52% · 251 games
190 C
20.51% · 846 games
191 C
20.5% · 317 games
192 C
20.5% · 300 games
193 C
20.5% · 361 games
194 C
20.49% · 5080 games
195 C
20.48% · 332 games
196 C
20.44% · 417 games
197 C
20.39% · 694 games
198 C
20.39% · 1214 games
199 C
20.38% · 444 games
201 C
20.37% · 394 games
202 C
20.34% · 687 games
203 C
20.32% · 754 games
204 C
20.32% · 379 games
205 C
20.29% · 2358 games
206 C
20.23% · 304 games
207 C
20.21% · 1951 games
209 C
20.14% · 257 games
210 C
20.14% · 406 games
211 C
20.13% · 636 games
212 C
20.09% · 1111 games
213 C
20.09% · 1038 games
214 C
20.07% · 507 games
215 C
20.06% · 6163 games
216 C
20.06% · 5881 games
217 C
20.06% · 678 games
218 C
20.05% · 9517 games
219 C
20.04% · 393 games
220 C
20.01% · 371 games
221 C
19.97% · 2892 games
222 C
19.89% · 2866 games
223 C
19.86% · 1172 games
224 C
19.86% · 1016 games
225 C
19.85% · 718 games
226 C
19.83% · 329 games
227 C
19.82% · 3373 games
228 C
19.79% · 379 games
229 C
19.77% · 473 games
230 C
19.76% · 873 games
231 C
19.75% · 524 games
232 C
19.7% · 302 games
233 C
19.68% · 3743 games
234 C
19.65% · 416 games
235 C
19.64% · 387 games
236 C
19.63% · 754 games
237 C
19.62% · 274 games
238 C
19.61% · 2520 games
239 C
19.58% · 1195 games
240 C
19.57% · 1431 games
241 C
19.57% · 773 games
242 C
19.56% · 998 games
243 C
19.54% · 1063 games
244 C
19.49% · 286 games
245 C
19.49% · 286 games
246 C
19.49% · 603 games
247 C
19.48% · 494 games
248 C
19.48% · 403 games
249 C
19.4% · 366 games
250 C
19.34% · 265 games
251 C
19.29% · 3048 games
252 C
19.27% · 279 games
253 C
19.25% · 335 games
254 C
19.24% · 1905 games
255 C
19.23% · 2440 games
256 C
19.18% · 335 games
257 C
19.16% · 775 games
260 C
19.03% · 653 games
261 C
18.97% · 1178 games
262 C
18.91% · 464 games
263 C
18.91% · 1166 games
264 C
18.88% · 286 games
265 C
18.87% · 661 games
266 C
18.85% · 252 games
267 C
18.81% · 784 games
268 C
18.79% · 862 games
269 C
18.78% · 466 games
270 C
18.76% · 14727 games
271 C
18.76% · 2003 games
272 C
18.69% · 408 games
273 C
18.66% · 284 games
274 C
18.66% · 974 games
275 C
18.65% · 390 games
276 C
18.63% · 357 games
277 C
18.62% · 584 games
278 C
18.62% · 380 games
279 C
18.59% · 1893 games
280 C
18.53% · 672 games
281 C
18.52% · 1238 games
282 C
18.5% · 623 games
283 C
18.48% · 705 games
284 C
18.46% · 1189 games
285 C
18.46% · 344 games
286 C
18.41% · 1093 games
287 C
18.37% · 358 games
288 C
18.36% · 2850 games
289 C
18.35% · 489 games
290 C
18.32% · 367 games
291 C
18.32% · 1894 games
292 C
18.32% · 625 games
293 C
18.31% · 314 games
294 C
18.3% · 519 games
295 C
18.3% · 418 games
296 C
18.3% · 306 games
297 C
18.3% · 1525 games
298 C
18.29% · 946 games
299 C
18.28% · 309 games
300 C
18.28% · 435 games
301 C
18.27% · 431 games
302 C
18.27% · 1638 games
303 C
18.26% · 538 games
304 C
18.26% · 304 games
305 C
18.18% · 854 games
306 C
18.15% · 1774 games
308 C
18.09% · 1639 games
309 C
18.08% · 253 games
D
Below 18% Win Rate

D-Tier: Weak Commanders (Below 18% Win Rate)

63
Entries

Winning significantly less than expected.

1 D
17.98% · 1388 games
2 D
17.89% · 964 games
3 D
17.82% · 303 games
4 D
17.82% · 404 games
5 D
17.81% · 313 games
6 D
17.75% · 414 games
7 D
17.73% · 1090 games
8 D
17.7% · 267 games
9 D
17.62% · 271 games
10 D
17.58% · 633 games
11 D
17.56% · 1327 games
12 D
17.54% · 315 games
13 D
17.5% · 290 games
14 D
17.47% · 724 games
15 D
17.47% · 365 games
16 D
17.41% · 3753 games
17 D
17.37% · 577 games
18 D
17.33% · 1128 games
19 D
17.33% · 264 games
20 D
17.24% · 435 games
21 D
17.22% · 1598 games
22 D
17.21% · 2761 games
23 D
17.21% · 292 games
24 D
17.2% · 917 games
25 D
17.19% · 1284 games
26 D
17.18% · 1652 games
27 D
17.16% · 1078 games
28 D
17.0% · 597 games
29 D
16.96% · 252 games
30 D
16.95% · 1625 games
31 D
16.77% · 1012 games
32 D
16.72% · 876 games
33 D
16.72% · 495 games
34 D
16.7% · 488 games
35 D
16.64% · 5204 games
36 D
16.57% · 430 games
37 D
16.53% · 708 games
38 D
16.52% · 619 games
39 D
16.47% · 906 games
40 D
16.45% · 491 games
41 D
16.34% · 329 games
42 D
16.33% · 799 games
43 D
15.98% · 341 games
44 D
15.94% · 469 games
45 D
15.83% · 510 games
46 D
15.63% · 323 games
47 D
15.5% · 1247 games
48 D
15.3% · 2396 games
49 D
15.28% · 252 games
50 D
15.14% · 1095 games
51 D
14.96% · 448 games
52 D
14.85% · 2207 games
53 D
14.8% · 299 games
54 D
14.75% · 473 games
55 D
14.65% · 998 games
56 D
57 D
14.48% · 870 games
58 D
14.23% · 267 games
59 D
14.07% · 279 games
60 D
14.0% · 384 games
61 D
13.6% · 388 games
62 D
12.62% · 723 games
63 D
11.05% · 328 games

Frequently Asked

What is the best Commander in MTG right now?
By win rate across all tracked Commander games, the top Commanders on Playgroup.gg are Hidetsugu and Kairi (48.49%), Narset, Enlightened Master (41.3%), and Rhoda, Geist Avenger (39.72%). These rankings come from real tracked games, normalized to a 4-player baseline, and refresh every 6 hours.
How is the Playgroup.gg Commander tier list calculated?
Every commander with at least 250 tracked games and at least 10 distinct registered pilots across all tracked Commander games is ranked by normalized win rate. Win rates are adjusted to a 4-player baseline (25% expected) so a win in a 2-player game and a win in a 5-player game are weighted fairly. Commanders scoring 35% or more are S-tier; 30-35% are A-tier; 23-30% are B-tier; 18-23% are C-tier; and below 18% are D-tier.
What does each tier mean?
S-tier commanders win roughly 40% more games than expected. A-tier wins about 20-40% above expected. B-tier is near the statistical baseline. C-tier is below average. D-tier commanders score below 18%, significantly under the 25% baseline. All values are normalized across pod sizes.
How often is the Commander tier list updated?
The data refreshes every 6 hours and is based on all tracked games to date.
Why is my commander not on the tier list?
A commander needs at least 250 tracked games across all tracked Commander games, and those games must come from at least 10 different registered pilots. The pilot diversity floor stops a single playgroup or grinder from skewing the ranking with their pet deck. You can still see all-time stats on any commander's individual page.
How is this different from EDHREC rankings or other tier lists?
EDHREC ranks by deck popularity, counting how many people register a commander. Other tier lists like Draftsim are based on editorial opinion. Playgroup.gg ranks by actual game win rates across thousands of casual Commander games tracked through the Playgroup.gg app and Playgroup Live each month.