Data-Backed · Win Rates

Commander Tier List

Playgroup.gg ranks 965 commanders into five tiers by win rate across 151,453 tracked casual Commander games from the last 180 days. The first Commander tier list based on real gameplay data, not opinions or deck registrations.

As of July 2026, the top Commanders by win rate are Narset, Enlightened Master (49.34%), Azami, Lady of Scrolls (45.2%), and Katara, Waterbending Master (41.67%), from 151,453 tracked games.

965
Ranked
151,453
Games
Methodology
Last Updated

Tiers are assigned by win rate in the rolling last 180 days window. Win rates are normalized to a 4-player baseline (25% expected) so games with different pod sizes are weighted fairly. A commander needs at least 100 tracked games to qualify, and those games must come from at least 10 distinct registered pilots so a single playgroup cannot dominate the ranking. Data comes from games recorded playing paper magic through the Playgroup.gg app and online games played with Playgroup Live. Win rates are calculated from both registered-deck and guest-commander participations.

S 35%+ Win Rate
A 30-35% Win Rate
B 23-30% Win Rate
C 18-23% Win Rate
D Below 18% Win Rate
S
35%+ Win Rate

S-Tier: Dominant Commanders (35%+ Win Rate)

40
Entries

Winning 40% more often than expected in 4-player pods.

1 S
49.34% · 417 games · ~
2 S
45.2% · 151 games · +5.2%
3 S
41.67% · 111 games · NEW
4 S
5 S
6 S
40.05% · 309 games · +9.43%
7 S
39.75% · 100 games · NEW
8 S
39.41% · 111 games · +4.36%
9 S
39.08% · 174 games · +5.85%
10 S
38.43% · 121 games · +6.5%
11 S
37.84% · 331 games · ~
12 S
37.33% · 225 games · +10.82%
13 S
37.17% · 489 games · +4.96%
14 S
37.03% · 106 games · NEW
15 S
37.02% · 156 games · NEW
16 S
36.68% · 184 games · ~
17 S
36.63% · 404 games · ~
18 S
36.55% · 394 games · NEW
19 S
36.52% · 102 games · NEW
20 S
36.49% · 111 games · NEW
21 S
36.28% · 696 games · ~
22 S
36.17% · 488 games · NEW
23 S
36.14% · 166 games · +8.59%
24 S
36.07% · 131 games · +7.84%
25 S
36.06% · 2086 games · NEW
26 S
35.88% · 462 games · NEW
28 S
35.71% · 217 games · +3.09%
29 S
35.71% · 154 games · NEW
30 S
35.67% · 375 games · ~
31 S
35.58% · 104 games · +10.32%
32 S
35.45% · 165 games · +8.26%
33 S
35.44% · 376 games · -4.27%
34 S
35.41% · 281 games · +5.39%
35 S
35.4% · 493 games · +3.6%
36 S
35.2% · 152 games · ~
37 S
35.09% · 114 games · NEW
38 S
35.05% · 102 games · NEW
39 S
35.03% · 314 games · +6.03%
40 S
35.0% · 195 games · -4.47%
A
30-35% Win Rate

A-Tier: Strong Commanders (30-35% Win Rate)

137
Entries

Consistently above the 25% expected baseline.

2 A
34.93% · 340 games · +4.78%
3 A
34.93% · 136 games · +11.29%
4 A
34.88% · 172 games · ~
5 A
34.69% · 498 games · -3.38%
6 A
34.69% · 160 games · +9.54%
7 A
34.63% · 109 games · +6.11%
8 A
34.5% · 129 games · NEW
9 A
34.48% · 1356 games · +3.54%
10 A
34.42% · 772 games · NEW
11 A
34.42% · 154 games · +12.9%
12 A
34.39% · 157 games · ~
13 A
34.32% · 110 games · NEW
14 A
15 A
34.18% · 196 games · NEW
16 A
34.18% · 147 games · +9.18%
17 A
34.1% · 338 games · ~
18 A
34.06% · 240 games · -12.41%
19 A
34.06% · 1223 games · ~
20 A
34.04% · 509 games · ~
21 A
34.0% · 1044 games · ~
22 A
33.94% · 369 games · ~
23 A
33.94% · 288 games · +3.19%
24 A
33.93% · 154 games · +12.43%
25 A
33.93% · 238 games · +3.88%
26 A
33.89% · 416 games · ~
27 A
33.82% · 136 games · +6.18%
28 A
33.73% · 106 games · ~
29 A
33.72% · 410 games · +8.04%
30 A
33.72% · 152 games · NEW
31 A
33.68% · 380 games · +4.81%
32 A
33.64% · 622 games · ~
33 A
33.63% · 281 games · +3.49%
34 A
33.57% · 105 games · ~
35 A
33.57% · 385 games · +3.21%
36 A
33.54% · 1379 games · ~
37 A
33.47% · 590 games · ~
38 A
33.42% · 597 games · ~
39 A
33.4% · 122 games · +5.21%
40 A
33.37% · 212 games · ~
41 A
33.29% · 519 games · -5.77%
42 A
33.28% · 3089 games · ~
43 A
33.23% · 167 games · +8.69%
44 A
33.18% · 220 games · +5.34%
45 A
33.16% · 141 games · +6.11%
46 A
33.11% · 336 games · ~
47 A
33.11% · 111 games · NEW
48 A
33.0% · 603 games · +3.75%
49 A
32.97% · 204 games · +3.44%
50 A
32.91% · 218 games · +9.08%
51 A
32.81% · 160 games · ~
52 A
32.8% · 202 games · +9.25%
53 A
32.77% · 103 games · NEW
54 A
32.75% · 313 games · +6.81%
55 A
32.58% · 531 games · +3.26%
56 A
32.5% · 260 games · ~
57 A
32.48% · 127 games · +9.98%
58 A
32.45% · 151 games · -7.1%
59 A
32.43% · 1423 games · ~
60 A
32.43% · 1363 games · ~
61 A
32.42% · 846 games · ~
62 A
32.39% · 362 games · +4.3%
63 A
32.37% · 139 games · ~
64 A
32.33% · 300 games · +5.67%
65 A
32.24% · 114 games · NEW
66 A
32.23% · 249 games · ~
67 A
32.22% · 135 games · NEW
68 A
32.22% · 135 games · +3.65%
69 A
32.14% · 560 games · ~
70 A
32.13% · 242 games · NEW
71 A
32.09% · 282 games · ~
72 A
32.0% · 318 games · ~
73 A
31.99% · 501 games · +3.57%
74 A
75 A
31.92% · 7421 games · NEW
76 A
31.91% · 329 games · +3.96%
77 A
31.9% · 518 games · +6.53%
78 A
31.83% · 1201 games · +3.24%
79 A
31.8% · 136 games · ~
80 A
31.8% · 853 games · +4.13%
81 A
31.79% · 287 games · ~
82 A
31.78% · 273 games · ~
83 A
31.75% · 904 games · +4.55%
84 A
31.74% · 4390 games · ~
85 A
31.71% · 298 games · +7.79%
86 A
31.59% · 148 games · +10.58%
87 A
31.52% · 280 games · +6.85%
88 A
31.43% · 490 games · -5.99%
89 A
31.41% · 199 games · +3.63%
90 A
31.36% · 165 games · NEW
91 A
31.31% · 1899 games · ~
92 A
31.23% · 369 games · ~
93 A
31.23% · 293 games · ~
94 A
31.2% · 125 games · +5.6%
95 A
31.17% · 332 games · +3.13%
96 A
31.14% · 171 games · NEW
97 A
31.13% · 212 games · +5.6%
98 A
31.07% · 107 games · NEW
99 A
31.07% · 272 games · ~
100 A
31.05% · 442 games · ~
101 A
31.05% · 252 games · ~
102 A
31.04% · 149 games · +5.89%
103 A
31.03% · 912 games · ~
104 A
31.02% · 108 games · NEW
105 A
30.9% · 619 games · ~
106 A
30.89% · 382 games · ~
107 A
30.87% · 3339 games · ~
108 A
30.85% · 201 games · +6.5%
109 A
30.83% · 150 games · NEW
110 A
30.83% · 416 games · +4.14%
111 A
30.81% · 129 games · -5.07%
112 A
30.8% · 168 games · NEW
113 A
30.78% · 398 games · NEW
114 A
30.77% · 1062 games · ~
115 A
30.75% · 100 games · -5.41%
116 A
30.66% · 106 games · NEW
117 A
30.59% · 398 games · ~
118 A
30.58% · 667 games · +3.46%
119 A
30.58% · 103 games · +3.25%
120 A
30.58% · 103 games · +3.47%
121 A
30.53% · 384 games · ~
122 A
30.52% · 172 games · ~
124 A
30.45% · 1013 games · ~
125 A
30.43% · 387 games · -3.43%
126 A
30.41% · 222 games · ~
127 A
30.32% · 456 games · NEW
128 A
30.32% · 489 games · ~
129 A
30.19% · 462 games · -5.73%
130 A
30.19% · 106 games · +8.26%
131 A
30.18% · 198 games · ~
132 A
30.12% · 244 games · +3.93%
133 A
30.08% · 177 games · +6.82%
134 A
30.08% · 713 games · -4.08%
135 A
30.07% · 153 games · +5.44%
136 A
30.04% · 1220 games · ~
137 A
30.0% · 220 games · +3.84%
B
23-30% Win Rate

B-Tier: Average Commanders (23-30% Win Rate)

494
Entries

Near the expected win rate for 4-player Commander.

1 B
29.97% · 156 games · +4.32%
2 B
29.96% · 116 games · NEW
3 B
29.95% · 212 games · ~
4 B
29.94% · 172 games · -4.68%
5 B
29.88% · 405 games · +5.3%
6 B
29.87% · 529 games · +3.55%
7 B
29.86% · 278 games · -3.35%
8 B
29.85% · 1717 games · ~
9 B
29.85% · 227 games · +7.82%
10 B
29.81% · 1129 games · ~
11 B
29.8% · 318 games · ~
12 B
13 B
29.79% · 3105 games · ~
14 B
29.7% · 149 games · +9.7%
15 B
29.69% · 128 games · NEW
16 B
29.62% · 1732 games · ~
17 B
29.62% · 249 games · NEW
18 B
29.61% · 141 games · ~
19 B
29.61% · 396 games · +5.29%
20 B
29.6% · 261 games · ~
21 B
29.58% · 464 games · ~
22 B
29.56% · 1108 games · ~
23 B
29.54% · 788 games · ~
24 B
29.51% · 521 games · ~
25 B
29.5% · 372 games · ~
26 B
29.49% · 217 games · ~
27 B
29.48% · 106 games · ~
28 B
29.46% · 112 games · NEW
29 B
29.41% · 1665 games · ~
30 B
29.4% · 159 games · +4.4%
31 B
29.38% · 160 games · +3.85%
32 B
29.38% · 600 games · ~
33 B
29.37% · 962 games · ~
34 B
29.35% · 1696 games · NEW
35 B
29.33% · 1823 games · ~
36 B
29.32% · 636 games · ~
37 B
29.31% · 400 games · ~
38 B
29.31% · 116 games · ~
39 B
29.31% · 650 games · ~
40 B
29.26% · 358 games · -4.65%
41 B
29.25% · 4218 games · ~
42 B
29.2% · 220 games · +5.59%
43 B
29.2% · 113 games · NEW
44 B
29.2% · 405 games · +4.08%
45 B
29.19% · 215 games · ~
46 B
29.18% · 287 games · ~
47 B
29.18% · 467 games · +4.29%
48 B
29.17% · 144 games · ~
49 B
29.17% · 132 games · NEW
50 B
29.14% · 308 games · ~
51 B
29.14% · 417 games · ~
52 B
29.1% · 469 games · -5.73%
53 B
29.1% · 396 games · ~
54 B
29.09% · 367 games · +5.45%
55 B
29.08% · 949 games · ~
56 B
29.05% · 5083 games · ~
57 B
29.04% · 439 games · ~
58 B
29.03% · 217 games · ~
59 B
29.01% · 349 games · -3.06%
60 B
29.0% · 782 games · ~
61 B
28.97% · 868 games · ~
63 B
28.96% · 158 games · NEW
64 B
28.95% · 373 games · ~
65 B
28.93% · 375 games · ~
66 B
28.92% · 153 games · ~
67 B
28.92% · 613 games · ~
68 B
28.88% · 174 games · +8.92%
69 B
28.85% · 104 games · NEW
70 B
28.82% · 144 games · +5.65%
71 B
28.79% · 336 games · ~
72 B
28.79% · 178 games · ~
73 B
28.77% · 411 games · ~
74 B
28.76% · 173 games · ~
75 B
28.74% · 508 games · NEW
76 B
28.74% · 448 games · +4.31%
77 B
28.74% · 1579 games · ~
78 B
28.73% · 577 games · +3.02%
79 B
28.69% · 447 games · ~
80 B
28.65% · 137 games · NEW
81 B
28.63% · 358 games · ~
82 B
28.61% · 201 games · +4.42%
83 B
28.55% · 211 games · +6.54%
85 B
28.53% · 276 games · +5.63%
86 B
28.47% · 303 games · +3.8%
87 B
28.46% · 166 games · ~
88 B
28.44% · 842 games · ~
89 B
28.42% · 278 games · ~
90 B
28.41% · 132 games · ~
91 B
28.39% · 383 games · ~
92 B
28.39% · 140 games · NEW
93 B
28.38% · 111 games · NEW
94 B
28.36% · 327 games · ~
95 B
28.36% · 223 games · +6.07%
96 B
28.36% · 320 games · -4.86%
97 B
28.35% · 1067 games · ~
98 B
28.35% · 1067 games · ~
99 B
28.34% · 740 games · ~
100 B
28.33% · 120 games · +5.5%
101 B
28.33% · 105 games · -5.11%
102 B
28.32% · 143 games · ~
103 B
28.31% · 189 games · ~
104 B
28.3% · 288 games · ~
105 B
28.3% · 311 games · ~
106 B
28.25% · 123 games · +5.51%
107 B
28.25% · 100 games · NEW
108 B
28.24% · 108 games · +5.34%
109 B
28.21% · 187 games · -10.41%
110 B
28.21% · 1209 games · ~
111 B
28.19% · 259 games · ~
112 B
28.18% · 661 games · -3.07%
113 B
28.17% · 308 games · -3.23%
114 B
28.1% · 145 games · ~
115 B
28.08% · 552 games · ~
116 B
28.06% · 139 games · +6.55%
117 B
28.05% · 164 games · ~
118 B
28.03% · 231 games · ~
119 B
28.02% · 2598 games · ~
120 B
27.99% · 978 games · ~
121 B
27.94% · 2329 games · ~
122 B
27.94% · 502 games · -3.47%
123 B
27.93% · 162 games · +4.48%
124 B
27.93% · 435 games · +5.16%
125 B
27.91% · 103 games · NEW
126 B
27.91% · 4015 games · ~
127 B
27.87% · 1367 games · ~
128 B
27.86% · 629 games · ~
129 B
27.86% · 525 games · ~
130 B
27.82% · 186 games · +7.9%
131 B
27.82% · 939 games · ~
132 B
27.76% · 362 games · +3.69%
133 B
27.73% · 110 games · -3.17%
134 B
27.72% · 101 games · NEW
135 B
27.69% · 614 games · ~
136 B
27.68% · 289 games · ~
137 B
27.68% · 867 games · +4.21%
138 B
27.67% · 243 games · ~
139 B
27.67% · 159 games · ~
140 B
27.65% · 368 games · +5.36%
141 B
27.61% · 115 games · NEW
142 B
27.6% · 125 games · NEW
143 B
27.51% · 1325 games · +3.28%
144 B
27.5% · 140 games · +4.18%
145 B
27.5% · 1500 games · +5.2%
146 B
27.5% · 551 games · +3.78%
147 B
27.48% · 272 games · +4.59%
148 B
27.48% · 1181 games · ~
149 B
27.46% · 142 games · ~
150 B
27.45% · 102 games · NEW
151 B
27.42% · 807 games · ~
152 B
27.41% · 197 games · ~
153 B
27.41% · 2451 games · ~
154 B
27.41% · 239 games · ~
155 B
27.4% · 208 games · ~
156 B
27.4% · 292 games · +7.82%
157 B
27.37% · 169 games · +3.8%
158 B
27.36% · 318 games · ~
159 B
27.36% · 594 games · ~
160 B
27.33% · 118 games · NEW
161 B
27.32% · 1951 games · ~
162 B
27.31% · 108 games · ~
163 B
27.3% · 283 games · ~
164 B
27.3% · 958 games · ~
165 B
27.3% · 479 games · ~
166 B
27.29% · 1092 games · ~
167 B
27.28% · 383 games · ~
168 B
27.28% · 307 games · +5.45%
169 B
27.25% · 311 games · ~
170 B
27.24% · 323 games · ~
171 B
27.24% · 223 games · ~
172 B
27.22% · 237 games · ~
173 B
27.2% · 148 games · +9.78%
174 B
27.19% · 491 games · ~
175 B
27.17% · 277 games · ~
176 B
27.16% · 1098 games · ~
177 B
27.16% · 486 games · ~
178 B
27.16% · 116 games · -7.64%
179 B
27.15% · 2031 games · ~
180 B
27.12% · 1110 games · ~
181 B
27.1% · 202 games · ~
182 B
27.09% · 549 games · ~
183 B
27.09% · 287 games · -5.23%
184 B
27.08% · 252 games · +8.43%
185 B
27.08% · 228 games · -3.45%
186 B
27.07% · 121 games · -9.44%
187 B
27.04% · 245 games · +3.6%
188 B
27.03% · 160 games · ~
189 B
27.01% · 335 games · -3.51%
191 B
26.99% · 817 games · +5.04%
192 B
26.97% · 863 games · ~
193 B
26.97% · 127 games · ~
194 B
26.96% · 268 games · ~
195 B
26.96% · 575 games · -4.39%
196 B
26.95% · 256 games · ~
197 B
26.95% · 308 games · +3.29%
198 B
26.91% · 2291 games · ~
199 B
26.9% · 382 games · +5.28%
200 B
26.9% · 606 games · ~
201 B
26.9% · 567 games · ~
202 B
26.9% · 211 games · -4.44%
203 B
26.88% · 1555 games · ~
204 B
26.88% · 173 games · +3.14%
205 B
26.86% · 295 games · ~
206 B
26.85% · 661 games · -3.78%
207 B
26.84% · 299 games · ~
208 B
26.81% · 124 games · ~
209 B
26.79% · 112 games · +4.17%
210 B
26.78% · 859 games · +5.34%
211 B
26.76% · 327 games · ~
212 B
26.75% · 884 games · ~
213 B
26.74% · 201 games · ~
214 B
26.69% · 237 games · ~
215 B
26.63% · 230 games · +3.5%
216 B
26.61% · 667 games · ~
217 B
26.61% · 342 games · NEW
218 B
26.6% · 250 games · +8.3%
219 B
26.56% · 240 games · +5.01%
220 B
26.56% · 128 games · ~
221 B
26.56% · 128 games · +7.3%
222 B
26.56% · 691 games · ~
223 B
26.55% · 1729 games · ~
224 B
26.54% · 651 games · ~
225 B
26.53% · 360 games · +3.34%
226 B
227 B
26.49% · 269 games · ~
228 B
26.49% · 101 games · NEW
229 B
26.48% · 928 games · ~
230 B
26.48% · 1063 games · ~
231 B
26.48% · 271 games · ~
232 B
26.47% · 459 games · +5.36%
233 B
26.46% · 1113 games · ~
234 B
26.46% · 206 games · NEW
235 B
26.44% · 139 games · NEW
236 B
26.42% · 264 games · ~
237 B
26.41% · 587 games · -4.61%
238 B
26.4% · 178 games · +3.69%
239 B
26.38% · 1882 games · ~
240 B
241 B
26.37% · 1757 games · ~
242 B
26.35% · 1669 games · ~
243 B
26.33% · 563 games · ~
244 B
26.33% · 245 games · NEW
245 B
26.32% · 190 games · ~
246 B
26.31% · 267 games · -3.24%
247 B
26.3% · 1458 games · ~
248 B
26.28% · 117 games · ~
249 B
26.27% · 668 games · ~
250 B
26.27% · 118 games · ~
251 B
26.27% · 632 games · ~
252 B
26.25% · 299 games · ~
253 B
26.22% · 797 games · ~
254 B
26.21% · 165 games · ~
255 B
26.17% · 171 games · ~
256 B
26.17% · 1951 games · ~
257 B
26.16% · 301 games · ~
258 B
26.14% · 176 games · ~
259 B
26.13% · 2152 games · ~
260 B
26.11% · 293 games · ~
261 B
26.07% · 512 games · ~
262 B
26.06% · 4520 games · ~
263 B
26.04% · 144 games · -4.15%
264 B
26.02% · 931 games · ~
265 B
25.99% · 101 games · -9.28%
266 B
25.95% · 105 games · NEW
267 B
25.94% · 133 games · -8.21%
268 B
25.92% · 1117 games · ~
269 B
25.9% · 1079 games · ~
270 B
25.89% · 112 games · +6.23%
271 B
25.88% · 171 games · +9.48%
272 B
25.88% · 428 games · ~
273 B
25.87% · 1373 games · ~
274 B
275 B
25.82% · 182 games · NEW
276 B
25.82% · 213 games · NEW
277 B
25.82% · 245 games · -4.22%
278 B
25.8% · 125 games · ~
279 B
25.79% · 126 games · ~
280 B
25.78% · 223 games · +6.93%
281 B
25.78% · 417 games · ~
282 B
25.77% · 323 games · ~
283 B
25.77% · 194 games · +3.04%
284 B
25.77% · 424 games · NEW
285 B
25.75% · 503 games · ~
286 B
25.73% · 103 games · -7.45%
287 B
25.72% · 485 games · -8.05%
288 B
25.72% · 104 games · ~
289 B
25.71% · 1866 games · ~
290 B
25.69% · 468 games · ~
291 B
25.69% · 109 games · ~
292 B
25.68% · 2035 games · -3.73%
293 B
25.67% · 112 games · NEW
294 B
25.67% · 262 games · ~
295 B
25.67% · 150 games · -7.73%
296 B
25.65% · 191 games · ~
297 B
25.65% · 459 games · ~
298 B
25.65% · 1267 games · ~
299 B
25.64% · 117 games · ~
300 B
25.63% · 279 games · ~
301 B
25.63% · 319 games · NEW
302 B
25.62% · 974 games · ~
303 B
25.61% · 165 games · ~
304 B
305 B
25.6% · 126 games · -8.62%
306 B
25.58% · 172 games · -5.93%
307 B
25.56% · 315 games · -3.39%
308 B
25.56% · 3152 games · ~
309 B
25.55% · 906 games · ~
310 B
25.55% · 272 games · +6.56%
311 B
25.55% · 870 games · ~
312 B
25.53% · 374 games · ~
313 B
25.5% · 1442 games · NEW
314 B
25.48% · 258 games · ~
315 B
25.47% · 953 games · ~
316 B
25.47% · 106 games · -7.86%
317 B
25.44% · 396 games · NEW
318 B
25.43% · 117 games · -3.18%
319 B
25.42% · 1318 games · ~
320 B
25.41% · 182 games · ~
321 B
25.41% · 123 games · ~
322 B
25.4% · 126 games · NEW
323 B
25.39% · 127 games · NEW
324 B
25.36% · 344 games · ~
325 B
25.34% · 221 games · ~
326 B
25.33% · 1060 games · ~
327 B
25.33% · 152 games · NEW
328 B
25.3% · 331 games · ~
329 B
25.23% · 330 games · ~
330 B
25.22% · 116 games · NEW
331 B
25.21% · 118 games · ~
332 B
25.2% · 128 games · NEW
333 B
25.18% · 999 games · ~
334 B
25.17% · 289 games · -3.58%
335 B
25.16% · 153 games · ~
336 B
25.14% · 351 games · ~
337 B
25.12% · 1209 games · ~
339 B
25.11% · 664 games · +4.74%
340 B
25.1% · 746 games · ~
341 B
25.09% · 285 games · ~
342 B
25.08% · 1910 games · ~
343 B
25.02% · 1136 games · ~
344 B
25.0% · 165 games · +5.06%
345 B
25.0% · 462 games · -5.14%
346 B
25.0% · 152 games · -4.0%
347 B
25.0% · 156 games · -3.31%
348 B
25.0% · 1309 games · ~
349 B
25.0% · 174 games · ~
350 B
25.0% · 454 games · +4.38%
351 B
25.0% · 120 games · +4.74%
352 B
25.0% · 135 games · NEW
353 B
25.0% · 281 games · ~
354 B
24.95% · 534 games · +3.45%
355 B
24.94% · 404 games · +6.26%
356 B
24.9% · 262 games · ~
357 B
24.9% · 2356 games · ~
358 B
24.9% · 2169 games · ~
359 B
24.87% · 3704 games · ~
360 B
24.87% · 1855 games · ~
361 B
24.86% · 914 games · ~
362 B
24.86% · 3471 games · ~
363 B
24.83% · 1147 games · ~
364 B
24.82% · 140 games · ~
365 B
24.8% · 127 games · NEW
366 B
24.77% · 109 games · ~
367 B
24.77% · 2356 games · ~
368 B
24.76% · 316 games · ~
369 B
24.76% · 104 games · ~
370 B
24.76% · 3201 games · ~
371 B
24.76% · 1135 games · ~
372 B
24.75% · 201 games · ~
373 B
24.71% · 940 games · ~
374 B
24.7% · 1835 games · ~
375 B
24.67% · 907 games · ~
376 B
24.65% · 217 games · +3.03%
377 B
24.65% · 144 games · -11.09%
378 B
24.65% · 502 games · ~
379 B
24.64% · 140 games · -3.84%
380 B
24.63% · 134 games · NEW
381 B
24.62% · 395 games · +4.14%
382 B
24.61% · 192 games · +4.75%
383 B
24.6% · 188 games · ~
384 B
24.57% · 233 games · -9.29%
385 B
24.57% · 115 games · ~
386 B
24.56% · 1313 games · ~
387 B
24.56% · 225 games · ~
388 B
24.55% · 165 games · +5.07%
389 B
24.53% · 429 games · ~
390 B
24.51% · 253 games · ~
391 B
24.49% · 146 games · -6.5%
392 B
24.48% · 676 games · ~
393 B
24.47% · 190 games · NEW
394 B
24.46% · 138 games · ~
395 B
24.41% · 1060 games · ~
396 B
24.4% · 208 games · -3.52%
397 B
24.39% · 246 games · ~
398 B
24.38% · 121 games · +12.55%
399 B
24.35% · 232 games · -7.43%
400 B
24.35% · 2775 games · ~
401 B
24.35% · 191 games · NEW
402 B
24.28% · 138 games · +3.57%
403 B
24.26% · 270 games · ~
404 B
24.23% · 422 games · ~
405 B
24.21% · 509 games · ~
406 B
24.18% · 245 games · ~
407 B
24.18% · 122 games · NEW
408 B
24.15% · 264 games · +5.9%
409 B
24.13% · 173 games · +8.68%
410 B
24.13% · 944 games · +3.54%
411 B
24.12% · 114 games · +7.31%
412 B
24.12% · 170 games · ~
413 B
24.11% · 280 games · ~
414 B
24.1% · 670 games · ~
415 B
24.07% · 188 games · ~
416 B
24.05% · 712 games · ~
417 B
24.05% · 263 games · NEW
418 B
24.04% · 130 games · ~
419 B
24.03% · 207 games · +4.06%
420 B
24.03% · 231 games · +3.56%
421 B
24.03% · 231 games · ~
422 B
24.02% · 563 games · -4.51%
423 B
24.01% · 1775 games · NEW
424 B
24.0% · 602 games · -3.54%
425 B
23.97% · 194 games · ~
426 B
23.96% · 2599 games · ~
427 B
23.95% · 167 games · -7.56%
428 B
23.94% · 283 games · NEW
429 B
23.92% · 302 games · -3.18%
430 B
23.88% · 378 games · +3.25%
431 B
23.86% · 372 games · ~
432 B
23.82% · 106 games · -6.42%
433 B
23.82% · 169 games · NEW
434 B
23.79% · 556 games · ~
435 B
23.72% · 312 games · ~
436 B
23.72% · 623 games · -4.16%
437 B
23.67% · 698 games · ~
438 B
23.67% · 433 games · -9.57%
439 B
23.67% · 263 games · ~
440 B
23.66% · 112 games · NEW
441 B
23.62% · 254 games · +8.41%
442 B
23.62% · 542 games · ~
443 B
23.59% · 585 games · ~
444 B
23.58% · 352 games · NEW
445 B
23.58% · 264 games · -3.73%
446 B
23.58% · 281 games · ~
447 B
23.57% · 227 games · ~
448 B
23.57% · 767 games · ~
449 B
23.57% · 122 games · ~
450 B
23.56% · 590 games · ~
451 B
23.56% · 2618 games · ~
452 B
23.56% · 104 games · ~
453 B
23.56% · 312 games · ~
454 B
23.53% · 170 games · ~
455 B
23.51% · 252 games · ~
456 B
23.5% · 100 games · NEW
457 B
23.49% · 215 games · ~
458 B
23.48% · 329 games · ~
459 B
23.45% · 323 games · ~
460 B
23.44% · 400 games · ~
461 B
23.43% · 287 games · -3.06%
462 B
23.42% · 206 games · +6.46%
463 B
23.4% · 219 games · ~
464 B
23.39% · 310 games · ~
465 B
23.37% · 999 games · ~
466 B
23.3% · 983 games · ~
467 B
23.28% · 204 games · -3.42%
468 B
23.28% · 2474 games · NEW
469 B
23.28% · 116 games · NEW
470 B
23.28% · 261 games · ~
471 B
23.25% · 986 games · ~
472 B
23.24% · 1253 games · ~
473 B
23.23% · 141 games · ~
474 B
23.2% · 236 games · ~
475 B
23.18% · 288 games · ~
476 B
23.15% · 352 games · ~
477 B
23.15% · 230 games · -4.69%
478 B
23.09% · 118 games · -13.2%
479 B
23.08% · 730 games · -3.75%
480 B
23.08% · 104 games · ~
481 B
23.08% · 117 games · NEW
482 B
23.06% · 103 games · NEW
483 B
23.06% · 399 games · ~
484 B
23.05% · 771 games · -4.04%
485 B
23.04% · 153 games · ~
486 B
487 B
23.03% · 127 games · -3.51%
488 B
23.03% · 127 games · -9.25%
489 B
23.02% · 139 games · NEW
490 B
23.02% · 2805 games · NEW
491 B
23.02% · 164 games · +4.2%
492 B
23.01% · 742 games · ~
493 B
23.01% · 3125 games · NEW
494 B
23.01% · 138 games · -7.51%
C
18-23% Win Rate

C-Tier: Below Average Commanders (18-23% Win Rate)

229
Entries

Underperforming the statistical baseline.

1 C
22.99% · 572 games · -5.86%
2 C
22.98% · 136 games · +6.96%
3 C
22.97% · 111 games · NEW
4 C
22.96% · 196 games · ~
5 C
22.95% · 305 games · ~
6 C
22.95% · 134 games · +4.47%
7 C
22.93% · 230 games · ~
8 C
22.93% · 133 games · NEW
9 C
10 C
22.93% · 169 games · NEW
11 C
22.93% · 181 games · ~
12 C
22.92% · 552 games · ~
13 C
22.91% · 1772 games · -3.84%
14 C
22.87% · 141 games · NEW
15 C
22.87% · 246 games · -7.95%
16 C
22.86% · 140 games · -3.62%
17 C
22.86% · 140 games · +3.11%
18 C
22.83% · 300 games · +6.59%
19 C
22.78% · 519 games · ~
20 C
22.74% · 166 games · NEW
21 C
22.73% · 628 games · ~
22 C
22.73% · 154 games · +3.4%
23 C
22.69% · 670 games · ~
24 C
22.69% · 270 games · ~
25 C
22.68% · 183 games · ~
26 C
22.65% · 309 games · ~
27 C
22.65% · 117 games · -3.06%
28 C
22.64% · 1048 games · ~
29 C
22.62% · 105 games · NEW
30 C
22.58% · 186 games · ~
31 C
22.57% · 371 games · ~
32 C
22.57% · 339 games · ~
33 C
22.55% · 541 games · ~
34 C
22.52% · 3561 games · ~
35 C
22.48% · 149 games · ~
36 C
22.48% · 119 games · +7.97%
37 C
22.47% · 178 games · ~
38 C
22.47% · 158 games · +3.75%
39 C
22.45% · 970 games · ~
40 C
22.45% · 382 games · ~
41 C
22.41% · 270 games · ~
42 C
22.41% · 135 games · NEW
43 C
22.37% · 695 games · ~
44 C
22.36% · 351 games · -5.12%
45 C
22.34% · 197 games · NEW
46 C
22.33% · 2120 games · ~
47 C
22.33% · 750 games · ~
48 C
22.32% · 401 games · ~
49 C
22.3% · 241 games · -5.1%
50 C
22.3% · 176 games · ~
51 C
22.28% · 101 games · NEW
52 C
22.24% · 380 games · NEW
53 C
22.22% · 144 games · ~
54 C
22.18% · 142 games · ~
55 C
22.17% · 2082 games · ~
56 C
22.16% · 194 games · +4.62%
57 C
22.16% · 915 games · ~
58 C
22.15% · 114 games · ~
60 C
22.11% · 570 games · -3.65%
61 C
22.1% · 414 games · ~
62 C
22.06% · 136 games · ~
63 C
22.05% · 696 games · +3.67%
64 C
22.04% · 279 games · +3.4%
65 C
22.0% · 1183 games · ~
66 C
21.98% · 248 games · NEW
67 C
21.96% · 189 games · ~
68 C
21.95% · 525 games · -5.07%
69 C
21.95% · 434 games · +3.4%
70 C
21.91% · 397 games · +3.77%
71 C
72 C
21.91% · 259 games · -5.54%
73 C
21.91% · 291 games · ~
74 C
21.84% · 190 games · -7.96%
75 C
21.8% · 281 games · ~
76 C
21.79% · 1277 games · ~
77 C
21.77% · 395 games · ~
78 C
21.77% · 147 games · NEW
79 C
21.76% · 108 games · ~
80 C
21.76% · 185 games · -4.58%
81 C
21.75% · 639 games · ~
82 C
21.75% · 123 games · ~
83 C
21.75% · 2428 games · NEW
84 C
21.71% · 213 games · -4.49%
85 C
21.64% · 610 games · -3.36%
86 C
87 C
21.64% · 171 games · ~
88 C
21.6% · 427 games · ~
89 C
21.58% · 373 games · ~
90 C
21.56% · 545 games · ~
91 C
21.56% · 356 games · -5.04%
92 C
21.55% · 181 games · +3.43%
93 C
21.53% · 137 games · -5.01%
94 C
21.53% · 137 games · -4.02%
95 C
21.5% · 1994 games · NEW
96 C
21.5% · 150 games · ~
97 C
21.49% · 970 games · ~
98 C
21.46% · 106 games · +3.77%
99 C
21.45% · 691 games · ~
100 C
21.45% · 289 games · -3.55%
101 C
102 C
21.43% · 119 games · +7.3%
103 C
21.41% · 341 games · -3.59%
104 C
21.39% · 844 games · ~
105 C
21.38% · 290 games · ~
106 C
21.36% · 1160 games · ~
107 C
21.34% · 752 games · ~
108 C
21.33% · 259 games · ~
109 C
21.27% · 208 games · ~
110 C
21.27% · 134 games · -9.77%
111 C
21.26% · 107 games · NEW
112 C
21.26% · 401 games · NEW
113 C
21.26% · 167 games · ~
114 C
21.26% · 187 games · -5.24%
115 C
21.25% · 307 games · +4.8%
116 C
21.25% · 140 games · ~
117 C
21.12% · 129 games · -3.2%
118 C
21.12% · 161 games · +3.86%
119 C
21.07% · 197 games · -3.72%
120 C
21.06% · 1156 games · ~
121 C
21.03% · 170 games · NEW
122 C
21.03% · 365 games · -3.45%
123 C
20.91% · 422 games · ~
124 C
20.89% · 140 games · -10.71%
125 C
20.88% · 649 games · -8.21%
126 C
20.88% · 188 games · -4.98%
127 C
20.87% · 109 games · -5.6%
128 C
20.86% · 766 games · ~
129 C
20.84% · 842 games · ~
130 C
20.83% · 749 games · NEW
131 C
20.79% · 309 games · NEW
132 C
20.76% · 236 games · ~
133 C
20.76% · 118 games · NEW
134 C
20.74% · 182 games · ~
135 C
20.74% · 135 games · -3.88%
136 C
20.74% · 176 games · NEW
137 C
20.73% · 585 games · +3.6%
138 C
20.67% · 104 games · ~
139 C
20.67% · 566 games · ~
140 C
20.65% · 178 games · ~
141 C
20.63% · 303 games · ~
142 C
20.59% · 589 games · ~
143 C
20.52% · 134 games · +5.43%
144 C
20.52% · 134 games · +3.91%
145 C
20.52% · 603 games · ~
146 C
20.45% · 231 games · -3.58%
147 C
20.41% · 447 games · ~
148 C
20.41% · 185 games · ~
149 C
20.38% · 503 games · -5.69%
150 C
20.37% · 189 games · NEW
151 C
20.37% · 135 games · -4.32%
152 C
20.32% · 379 games · NEW
153 C
20.31% · 639 games · ~
154 C
20.29% · 276 games · -5.62%
155 C
20.29% · 260 games · -5.38%
156 C
20.27% · 185 games · ~
157 C
20.25% · 158 games · -3.51%
158 C
20.25% · 142 games · ~
159 C
20.19% · 421 games · ~
160 C
20.16% · 124 games · -8.44%
161 C
20.15% · 923 games · NEW
162 C
20.13% · 600 games · ~
163 C
20.09% · 866 games · ~
164 C
20.09% · 280 games · ~
165 C
20.08% · 264 games · ~
166 C
20.07% · 1039 games · NEW
167 C
20.05% · 5879 games · NEW
168 C
19.98% · 732 games · ~
169 C
19.97% · 189 games · -5.03%
170 C
19.96% · 129 games · -5.71%
171 C
19.9% · 103 games · ~
172 C
19.9% · 382 games · -6.53%
173 C
19.85% · 170 games · -3.49%
174 C
19.85% · 2222 games · ~
175 C
19.8% · 101 games · -6.4%
176 C
177 C
19.74% · 233 games · -7.9%
178 C
19.69% · 584 games · ~
179 C
19.69% · 254 games · +4.06%
180 C
19.59% · 370 games · ~
181 C
19.58% · 480 games · -7.95%
182 C
19.55% · 156 games · ~
183 C
19.51% · 237 games · ~
184 C
19.5% · 969 games · ~
185 C
19.44% · 270 games · ~
186 C
19.39% · 196 games · -4.7%
187 C
19.33% · 410 games · ~
188 C
19.33% · 163 games · ~
189 C
19.31% · 624 games · ~
190 C
19.31% · 224 games · -4.57%
191 C
19.28% · 188 games · -4.37%
192 C
19.27% · 179 games · ~
193 C
19.26% · 680 games · ~
194 C
19.24% · 573 games · ~
195 C
19.23% · 3364 games · ~
196 C
19.21% · 384 games · ~
197 C
19.19% · 155 games · ~
198 C
19.17% · 283 games · ~
199 C
19.15% · 252 games · -6.13%
200 C
19.13% · 166 games · ~
201 C
19.13% · 183 games · -7.01%
202 C
19.09% · 254 games · ~
203 C
19.08% · 249 games · ~
204 C
19.06% · 101 games · ~
205 C
19.0% · 125 games · ~
206 C
18.97% · 170 games · ~
207 C
18.96% · 120 games · NEW
208 C
18.86% · 277 games · ~
209 C
18.85% · 423 games · ~
210 C
18.81% · 101 games · NEW
211 C
18.75% · 196 games · ~
212 C
18.69% · 107 games · NEW
213 C
18.68% · 870 games · +5.31%
214 C
18.6% · 469 games · ~
215 C
18.59% · 156 games · NEW
216 C
18.48% · 399 games · ~
217 C
18.47% · 295 games · -4.57%
218 C
18.43% · 1229 games · -4.82%
219 C
18.38% · 136 games · NEW
220 C
18.37% · 132 games · ~
221 C
18.32% · 513 games · -3.14%
222 C
18.32% · 202 games · -4.55%
223 C
18.21% · 254 games · -5.78%
224 C
18.2% · 114 games · NEW
225 C
18.09% · 152 games · NEW
226 C
18.07% · 285 games · ~
227 C
18.04% · 115 games · NEW
228 C
18.01% · 397 games · ~
229 C
18.0% · 828 games · NEW
D
Below 18% Win Rate

D-Tier: Weak Commanders (Below 18% Win Rate)

65
Entries

Winning significantly less than expected.

1 D
17.99% · 289 games · ~
2 D
17.98% · 495 games · ~
3 D
17.92% · 106 games · ~
4 D
17.9% · 609 games · -4.3%
5 D
17.89% · 102 games · -3.82%
6 D
17.86% · 910 games · ~
7 D
17.76% · 145 games · -7.49%
8 D
17.7% · 137 games · -3.47%
9 D
17.67% · 307 games · -3.3%
10 D
17.56% · 178 games · -3.32%
11 D
17.47% · 176 games · ~
12 D
17.46% · 189 games · ~
13 D
17.36% · 203 games · NEW
14 D
17.31% · 104 games · NEW
15 D
17.3% · 198 games · ~
16 D
17.29% · 146 games · -7.52%
17 D
17.27% · 495 games · -3.88%
18 D
17.18% · 179 games · NEW
19 D
17.05% · 525 games · -5.68%
20 D
16.99% · 234 games · -3.97%
21 D
16.82% · 107 games · NEW
22 D
16.81% · 229 games · ~
23 D
16.77% · 252 games · -3.39%
24 D
16.7% · 488 games · NEW
25 D
16.56% · 237 games · ~
26 D
16.53% · 124 games · NEW
27 D
16.44% · 514 games · ~
28 D
16.36% · 440 games · -7.72%
29 D
16.29% · 132 games · ~
30 D
16.21% · 597 games · ~
31 D
16.17% · 133 games · NEW
32 D
16.14% · 110 games · NEW
33 D
15.92% · 223 games · ~
34 D
15.9% · 250 games · -4.14%
35 D
15.87% · 167 games · NEW
36 D
15.87% · 104 games · NEW
37 D
15.77% · 241 games · ~
38 D
15.76% · 360 games · ~
39 D
15.73% · 213 games · +5.35%
41 D
15.69% · 102 games · ~
42 D
15.68% · 362 games · NEW
43 D
15.56% · 853 games · ~
44 D
15.34% · 207 games · -7.49%
45 D
15.33% · 168 games · -3.79%
46 D
15.23% · 243 games · -5.18%
47 D
15.06% · 156 games · ~
48 D
14.96% · 264 games · -5.15%
49 D
14.64% · 152 games · ~
50 D
14.38% · 113 games · -6.92%
51 D
14.29% · 119 games · ~
52 D
14.13% · 161 games · -8.67%
53 D
14.05% · 185 games · -3.52%
54 D
13.77% · 227 games · ~
55 D
13.49% · 352 games · ~
56 D
12.94% · 141 games · NEW
57 D
12.72% · 114 games · NEW
58 D
12.56% · 195 games · -5.96%
59 D
12.36% · 184 games · -4.62%
60 D
11.42% · 116 games · -6.73%
61 D
11.29% · 124 games · -9.46%
62 D
11.08% · 158 games · ~
63 D
10.0% · 110 games · NEW
64 D
9.64% · 166 games · NEW
65 D
8.17% · 104 games · -4.33%

Frequently Asked

What is the best Commander in MTG right now?
By win rate in the last 180 days, the top Commanders on Playgroup.gg are Narset, Enlightened Master (49.34%), Azami, Lady of Scrolls (45.2%), and Katara, Waterbending Master (41.67%). These rankings come from real tracked games, normalized to a 4-player baseline, and refresh every 6 hours.
How is the Playgroup.gg Commander tier list calculated?
Every commander with at least 100 tracked games and at least 10 distinct registered pilots in the last 180 days is ranked by normalized win rate. Win rates are adjusted to a 4-player baseline (25% expected) so a win in a 2-player game and a win in a 5-player game are weighted fairly. Commanders scoring 35% or more are S-tier; 30-35% are A-tier; 23-30% are B-tier; 18-23% are C-tier; and below 18% are D-tier.
What does each tier mean?
S-tier commanders win roughly 40% more games than expected. A-tier wins about 20-40% above expected. B-tier is near the statistical baseline. C-tier is below average. D-tier commanders score below 18%, significantly under the 25% baseline. All values are normalized across pod sizes.
How often is the Commander tier list updated?
The data refreshes every 6 hours. Because it uses a last 180 days window, tiers shift gradually as new games are recorded and old ones age out.
Why is my commander not on the tier list?
A commander needs at least 100 tracked games in the last 180 days, and those games must come from at least 10 different registered pilots. The pilot diversity floor stops a single playgroup or grinder from skewing the ranking with their pet deck. You can still see all-time stats on any commander's individual page.
How is this different from EDHREC rankings or other tier lists?
EDHREC ranks by deck popularity, counting how many people register a commander. Other tier lists like Draftsim are based on editorial opinion. Playgroup.gg ranks by actual game win rates across thousands of casual Commander games tracked through the Playgroup.gg app and Playgroup Live each month.