Commander

Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher

Global commander stats {W} {B} All Orzhov commanders
Win Rate 35%
529 Wins
971 Losses
Playtest a community deck
Overview

Summary

Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher is a Magic: The Gathering commander tracked across 1,501 recorded Playgroup games, winning 35% of them (529971) at an Elo of 1,604, ranking #498 globally.

Wins average 9 turns, with 170343 damage dealt and 0.78 player kills per game on average.

Last full refresh
Sources Scryfall · EDHREC · JSON API

Frequently Asked

What is Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher's win rate?
Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher has a 35% win rate across 1501 recorded Playgroup games (529 wins, 971 losses).
How long do winning games with Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher take?
Wins with Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher take on average 9 turns. Total tracked play time: 19 days.
How many decks use Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher?
447 decks list Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher as their commander on Playgroup, of which 271 have played at least one recorded game.
Global rank
498
Wins by turn (avg.)
9
Elo rating
1604
Trend

Global Elo trend

Loading...
Trend

Commander popularity trend

Loading...
Averages

Misc. stats

Average damage per game 170343
Average commander damage per game 2090017
Average poison counters given per game 3
Average kills per game 0.78
Average turn length 2 minutes
No. decks for this commander 447
No. decks with at least one game for this commander 271
No. games played with this commander 1501
Total hours played 19 days
Community

Top 5 public decks

Rank Elo User Games Wins
1 1637 Magnus_the_Grixis 20 11
2 1607 jimbonator 7 5
3 1574 Franz 6 4
4 1565 Ethan Daughtry 21 7
5 1565 Klegbert 10 4
Outcomes

How does this commander win?

When Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher wins, 38.23% of wins come via combat across tracked games with a recorded win condition.

Combat
38.23%
Commander Damage
25.57%
Non Combat Damage
24.81%
Combo
8.1%
Alternative
2.28%
Mill
0.76%
Poison
0.25%
Avg win turn 9.4 based on 542 wins with recorded turn counts
Table position

Does seating order matter?

Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher wins 42.23% of games from position 1 and 20.59% from position 5 across tracked games.

1
Seat 1
42.23% n=457
2
Seat 2
37.26% n=416
3
Seat 3
27.35% n=351
4
Seat 4
27.97% n=236
5
Seat 5
20.59% n=34
6
Seat 6
33.33% n=3
Opening hands

Do mulligans hurt this commander?

Across tracked games, Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher wins 37.15% after 0 mulligans and 50.0% after 5 mulligans.

0
0 mulligans
37.15% n=751
1
1 mulligan
35.74% n=235
2
2 mulligans
30.59% n=85
3
3 mulligans
26.09% n=23
4
4 mulligans
0.0% n=3
5
5 mulligans
50.0% n=4
Player reports

How do players rate games with this commander?

Pilot rating

Pilots rate their own games with Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher 3.51/5 on average, across 958 self-reports.

3.51 / 5
🧂

Opponent salt

When Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher wins, opponents flag the game as salty 59.2% of the time across 544 tracked wins.

59.2 \%
Head to head

Best and worst matchups

Opposing commanders with at least ten tracked games against Carmen, Cruel Skymarcher. Pairs with fewer than 25 games are shown in italics; treat those as suggestive, not statistical.

Top 5 best matchups

Vial Smasher the Fierce commander art
66.67%
Satya, Aetherflux Genius commander art
60.0%
Zimone, Mystery Unraveler commander art
55.56%
Wick, the Whorled Mind commander art
54.55%
Kenrith, the Returned King commander art
54.55%

Top 5 worst matchups

Marchesa, the Black Rose commander art
8.33%
Miirym, Sentinel Wyrm commander art
9.09%
Kumena, Tyrant of Orazca commander art
10.0%
Galazeth Prismari commander art
10.0%